Will Carmen become bigger than Hearts2Hearts?

no

theyre from sm

every member will be at least decently popular

For now yes, but they are literally rookies who debuted days ago, all the members will have countless chances to be bigger and build their fb.

SEA members are always popular look at Ten from NCT and Lisa from BP! Plus Carmen is so cute and gives off good energy I was more surprised Ian fancam is almost doubled the rest! Then Jiwoo and Ana!

I know things could change but it seems Carmen, Ian, Jiwoo and Ana are the most popular for now!

I have a feeling Yuha and Juun (once we see more of what she can do) we blow up virally!

And Ana my bias she’s so pretty

maybe... she's adorable and seems talented . im sure she's gonna get quite popular. and not just because she indo.

she looks like a mix of yoona/chaeyoung/and even a bit of lisa in her smile .

honestly apart of her, nobody really catches my attention. not even jiwoo .

edit: my bad, i think stella has potential too

I'm still not convinced any of them will be big. They feel oddly nugu for an SM production.

Quote from Popper-of-Ks

I'm still not convinced any of them will be big. They feel oddly nugu for an SM production.

The same was said about aespa members lol

No one would get to Irene’s level etc give it time

Quote from foreveraespaaa

The same was said about aespa members lol

No one would get to Irene’s level etc give it time

I don't recall anyone saying that about Aespa. There were plenty of other negative things being said, but no one seemed to doubt their potential star power. They at least came out of the gate with a much more defined character than this group, even if not everyone liked it.

Quote from Popper-of-Ks

I don't recall anyone saying that about Aespa. There were plenty of other negative things being said, but no one seemed to doubt their potential star power. They at least came out of the gate with a much more defined character than this group, even if not everyone liked it.

Yes, people said that about Aespa too.

Quote from Popper-of-Ks

I don't recall anyone saying that about Aespa. There were plenty of other negative things being said, but no one seemed to doubt their potential star power. They at least came out of the gate with a much more defined character than this group, even if not everyone liked it.

Aespa had everything said about them? No star power, no wow factor, nugu visuals, overrated and overhyped, not pretty, sm media play, no standout, not sm visuals, will never reach Irene’s level I can go on and on

If anything aespa probably got it worse ( not to compare) with the predebut bully accusations and fake scandal of Karina calling a few idols ugly people said worse!

I think Black Mamba even get more dislikes than likes on melon and some other platforms

Quote from bagelbaguette

no

theyre from sm

every member will be at least decently popular

to add to my point

its not like this is some random group from a nugu company where one member suddenly goes viral and thats all people know about the group

this is an sm group we're talking about

every members gonna have a fanbase even from debut

Sm knows how to push a member, and it’s gonna be a korean. So to answer your question, no.

Doesn't really mean anything, she's the only non Korean ofc ppl from her country will be replaying over and over again all of her content.