Who is less innovative and more stuck in the 2010s? YG or JYP?

YG, jyp is indeed trying new things especially with nmixx.

was gonna say JYP because they have 2 underperforming GGs and YG has 0, but JYP is innovating I guess, just poorly. The thing is as long as the groups keep doing well I can't see them making any changes unfortunately.

YG. The songs actually sound the exact same as many many years ago. Not a single new idea.

JYP's GGs are at least trying some new and different things, it's just that none of it is sticking.

YG

I'm so disappointed in you, Yama. You're always excluding the "BOTH" option.

So, I'm not gonna pick anyone, because it's both for sure.

Neither, tbh, at least recently. That's not to say I don't like the sound, but it's not particularly innovative at all. YG just repeats its own sound and formula, and JYP just tries (and imo fails) to reinvent SM's.

Again, I do like NMIXX, but to build an identity around the "mixxpop" sound was never going to work because it's already lost it's shock value before they even debuted. Otherwise, aespa would just keep churning out Next Levels and Savages.

JYP songs don't feel dated they just have bad quality. All of YG's songs sound like they came from a 2013 demo vault.

YG is stuck in the 90s, JYP is stuck in the 10s

if jyp girl groups were releasing miss A type of music they would be doing a lot better.

maybe not great but better at least

yg. and ı think that's okey. those big labels all have their identity. sm known for their experimantal sounds while jyp's sound more lively etc. for ex. why would yg try to sound trendy, there is ton of groups and labels in kpop ent. people free to discover new things. so for me not changing is not that bad tho.

Quote from SooYoung

YG

Baby monster just feel like a continuation of blackpink

Besides the number of members i wouldn't be able to mention one thing that set them apart musically, concept wise etc....

And Treasure feel like the same exact thing but with Big bang

Display More

The lies specially with Treasure. They are nowhere near BB in concept, music, etc, like nothing about them remember BB.

Baemon is trying the GC formula, but it isn't working without Teddy so not exactly a BP copy, more like a Teddy copy that isn't as good as his works.

YGE. Their sound is still the same 2012~16 sound they had. BP songs sound way more "new" imo than some Baemon or Treasure songs and that says a lot and not just songs, their MVs took a hit quality wise too.

Jype is at least trying even though they are failing hard. So less innovative goes to YGE.

yg and this is totally their fault for always using teddy as the main producer for their 3 group