Did flower got wasted on jisoo?

Terrible song. Doesn't even have a chorus to sing. Fits her like a glove.

It's still top 10 on Melon and could be for another month, depending on how many singles NJ puts out. Its outperformed every other Kpop solo song since Taeyeon last year i think (maybe Nayeon can match it i cant remember Pop's chart performance). I dont think any other Kpop soloist could have done better with it, Jisoo killed it.

no the song suits her voice. yes she is on the struggle bus trying to hit those notes especially in all eyes on me, but I think it adds flavor to the songs. sometimes you need to have no talent in singing to make a song sound good. I just love her.

She sounded good imo. There were a few notes that were a little high for her but this song was within her relaxed range. Plus its success speaks for itself—if it was that bad it wouldn’t have done as well as it did, especially in Korea.

flower never wasted on pretty woman

Quote from thebadguy

Commercial performance of song is completely irrelevant, even if bp members release fart sound in name of song it would still do good

I specified in Korea because as with Lisa’s solo (even though I’m sure xenophobia probably played a part in her domestic performance) or Ice Cream, if Korea doesn’t like a BP or BP member song it won’t necessarily do well. So if Jisoo sounded as bad as you say she did then her solo wouldn’t have done as well as it’s doing—she’s not just peaking and falling, but holding steady.

And again, imo I don’t think the song is wasted on her. It’s not the best song ever but she suited the vibes and sounded great overall.

Flower overall is a very boring song imo. Though I know that many people clearly do not agree with me, which is fine.

It also does not seem too difficult to sing...which is probably for the best. That's all I'm gonna say.

Quote from curlyfriez

She sounded good imo. There were a few notes that were a little high for her but this song was within her relaxed range. Plus its success speaks for itself—if it was that bad it wouldn’t have done as well as it did, especially in Korea.

Jisoo's voice is normally husky. Also, there are different singing techniques that may seem weird to some people. Also, companies would just autotune their voices anyways..

Jisoo made this song interesting plus she was involved in the song she gave a lot of input in the concept

I wouldn't be surprised of the idea of the lyrics as well

Quote from curlyfriez

I specified in Korea because as with Lisa’s solo (even though I’m sure xenophobia probably played a part in her domestic performance) or Ice Cream, if Korea doesn’t like a BP or BP member song it won’t necessarily do well. So if Jisoo sounded as bad as you say she did then her solo wouldn’t have done as well as it’s doing—she’s not just peaking and falling, but holding steady.

And again, imo I don’t think the song is wasted on her. It’s not the best song ever but she suited the vibes and sounded great overall.

yeah she might not be the best vocalist but I was watching some vocal reactors and they liked her falsetto she tried something different ( since born pink actually like in the happiest girl)

also the parts people think she struggles is more like a cry compression. I don't know the terminology but someone explained it when they were reacting to her. it's an effect at least for this song I know she might struggle for songs that are too high but this one isn't super high so it's intentional.

I don't know this forum has that many hatters for jisoo. Also one can not like the song or their singing it's entirely depends on person perspective every one has own tastes and their interests. personally I like the song and it's suits her much.

No Flower was perfect for Jisoo. The song fits her and she fits the song.

Quote from thebadguy

Jisoo had no involvement with writing lyrics or production of the song, stop lying

I'm talking about the concept it's in the behind the scenes of her music viideo and her vlogs she talked about it.

she was pretty involved like the other members in their solos .

I only said I wouldn't be surprised if she gave some input since she ilikes poetry and stuff

( she had writing credits in the past ) but I was mostly talking about the concept of flower in general

flower.j.jpg

Jisoo disappeared! Where'd she go??

With or without Jisoo Flower is a mediocre song.

Continue to stream Flower op that's really valuable