between TWICE, BLACKPINK and RED VELVET....
-
-
-_-
-
-
-
-
-
-
are we talking about thee controversy itself or the impact it had on theeir career ???
Because if we talk about the controversy itself i would say Irene controversy was worst than tzuyu and Jisoo
but if we talk about the impact it had on their career, i would say Tzuyu because her controversy completely close a really big and important market for Kpop groups to Twice that's the reason why even if Twice were know to be the biggest GG in physical before now they hardly compete with Blackpink, Aespa or Ive
-
Irene lost all her brand deals and still hasn't been able to return back to the status she had pre-scandal. Went from being seen all over Korea at her peak and competing with the likes of Jennie and Hwasa to not getting anything after 2020. Probably one of the biggest downfalls in KPOP when you really think about it and she's very lucky that she was given somewhat of a second chance by alot of people.
I remember tracking charts at the time too and you could see a steep fall for Monster (though it was alr out of the top100 at the time). The fact that it got so bad they had to debut aespa fjkbg
Tzuyu would be 2nd imo honestly due to getting an entire country to hate and boycott her for what seems like a mere mistake, and I'd say to this day they still don't have a huge Chinese fanbase vs other 3rd gen GGs for this reason. But it didn't really have any noticeable impact on her brand or the group's brand overall as TWICE would literally annihilate the domestic charts soon after.
BLACKPINK's 'scandals' seem like really overblown issues by antis who desperately want them to fuck up
-
-
I think Tzuyu scandal caused a big hit tbh, but it's also the most stupid scandal on the list. Girl decided to lift the flag of her own country and people are mad.
But I think in the long term, Irene's controversy is the biggest consequence wise, she lost a lot of her sponserships, and controversial opinion but her top it-girl status too.
Jisoo's controversy was way overblown, the drama turned out to be nothing like what people said it was going to be. I don't think it really affected her popularity tbh. She's still very popular, and nowadays a lot more popular than she used to be say in 2019-2020.
-
-
-
Tzuyu.....
In TWICE's 7 years they have yet to have a Concert in Taiwan even though Itzy will have one.
Unlike BP or RV's scandals, none of them had the affect where China based Music Providers banned Music from their Companies like the Tzuyu incident did.
TWICE lost awards due to China based Sponsorships which affected Got7 from initially winning prizes.
Tzuyu's scandal affected the Politics of 2 Nations' and the worst thing was it was Korean's that f*cked up that didn't research the risks of waving the Taiwanese Flag.
It's the thing that p*sses me off that Korean Networks got off for their mistreatment of a Minor as none of those sell outs admitted to giving her the flag.
But what's even more pathetic is the Taiwanese Politicians that used Tzuyu as a pawn to win the Election.
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
