Do you think sm ent opened the portal for debuted the minors..in kpop

The fact that a 13yo wonyoung was made to perform a song like side to side on produce will never rest in my conscience

Everything kpop related. Good and bad can be traced back to SM. They started everything.

Quote from vivaliberta

The reasons wonyoung dislike sexualized herself now (she prefer elegant feminin concept)

yes i am with you..

Why you did changed the discussion about sm ent..and debuted minors

isn’t your discussion supposed to be about sm opening the floodgates for other companies also feeling fine about debuting 13 yos? Then why would me mentioning an example of such an instance committed by another company be off topic? It’s perfectly on topic in fact lol

Quote from Whi

The fact that a 13yo wonyoung was made to perform a song like side to side on produce will never rest in my conscience

that performance ruined my entire life. i remember it coming out and watching it out of curiousity because i ddin't want produce and the excitement LEAVING my soul

Quote from Whi

The fact that a 13yo wonyoung was made to perform a song like side to side on produce will never rest in my conscience

I had no clue what folks were talking about until a recent thread. I then looked up the Produce video and was like, the performance was a little provocative but hey, she's dressed in regular Kpop outfits nothing revealing. And then i finally looked up the lyrics and it was all about bicycles and tricycles and saw some interview where folks talked about the true meaning of side to side and i was like wonyoung.gif

Sm was literally the one to start idol system in SK and other followed their every move . And it's a rare sight to see a group full of adults in kpop unless debut is delayed for some reason.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

I had no clue what folks were talking about until a recent thread. I then looked up the Produce video and was like, the performance was a little provocative but hey, she's dressed in regular Kpop outfits nothing revealing. And then i finally looked up the lyrics and it was all about bicycles and tricycles and saw some interview where folks talked about the true meaning of side to side and i was like wonyoung.gif

lol ik the lyrics aren’t very obvious at first glance especially for folks not fluent in english or well versed in contemporary slangs (like boomers like you ) but I always thought the tagline “you got me walking side to side” is pretty quite obvious what it’s trying to say lol so yeah..

Quote from vivaliberta

I know boa has debuted at 13 years old as soloist in kpop industry (1998)

Now there is 2009 in big3 group

This is true, they have stoped debuted minors members in sm ent...but yet this is sm make that

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

3 k quotes...in 3 hours.

Display More

JESUS SHES ALMOST AS OLD AS MY SISTER

JYPE's first BG were 13 year old twins, Kim Ryang-hyun and Kim Ryang-ha

NMIXX's Lily was 12 at the time, she would turn 13 later in the year

Duet with Jo Seung Hyun of JACE

minor in entertainment industry are nothing new or unique to Korea an idol industry

just look at Disney track record

I believed SM is the one who started but they don't let their idols so sexy stuff when they are minors.

Quote from elliejr

Sm was literally the one to start idol system in SK and other followed their every move . And it's a rare sight to see a group full of adults in kpop unless debut is delayed for some reason.

Not that rare when some of the biggest groups did so. EXO, Aespa, blackpink

People are extremely weird to think children need to debut when there are popular groups both bg and gg that debuted as adults.

Quote from jimeous

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Ahhh, I miss this song!

Quote from ISaidISaid

Not that rare when some of the biggest groups did so. EXO, Aespa, blackpink

People are extremely weird to think children need to debut when there are popular groups both bg and gg that debuted as adults.

Blackpink and Aespa both group's debuts were delayed, and I had no idea about every exo member debuting as as adult.

Quote from elliejr

Blackpink and Aespa both group's debuts were delayed, and I had no idea about every exo member debuting as as adult.

Lol what a random argument. They debuted as adults and were all successful. There is no need to debut people below 17 for success. Kpop is just being creepy. Anyway you can’t call it rare when some of the biggest groups all debuted as adults.