I-DLE "GOOD THING" (GLOBAL & SOUTH KOREA) SPOTIFY NO WHERE TO BE FOUND

The fan are trying.

I wonder if the name change is confusing the casuals. I don't think there's a song like fate to overtake the title track. Also, I think we need to give it time because their charting will improve

That's bad. How are their album sales doing compared to their previous comebacks?

Quote from Seoged

That's bad. How are their album sales doing compared to their previous comebacks?

Good

Quote from Seoged

That's bad. How are their album sales doing compared to their previous comebacks?

Thread

I-DLE - We Are - 1st day/1st week sales - 465k

still counting
x.com/koreansales_twt/status/1924397047517413697

bartkun

May 19th 2025

They haven't been charting on Spotify Global It's been 2 years, so It's expected. But I'm not sure about Korea, maybe the re-brand affected them, at least initially?

Quote from StanGIDLE

Good

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

It's interesting how they are one of the only groups that haven't seen a significant drop in sales. Even their solo albums are doing very well.

Quote from Seoged

It's interesting how they are one of the only groups that haven't seen a significant drop in sales. Even their solo albums are doing very well.

Yeah, sales will always be there for this group imo. I think charting is trickier because they sometimes start slower than other groups. I am just not sure if "Good Thing" will be in the top 10 due to slow start and many groups comebacks are in late may - july

They haven't charted on Spotify for a long time so that is nothing unexpected.

Idle back to nugudom

But they haven’t charted on Spotify Global for a while now the only current active 4th gen GG’s that can do that is aespa and Le Sserafim so it’s to be expected. (New Jeans too but they’re inactive right now due to HYBE situation)

Korea is where they do best I think it’s too early to tell but I feel like the song has potential to rise.

When they said re-debut, they really did mean re-debut.

Quote from StanGIDLE

I wonder if the name change is confusing the casuals. I don't think there's a song like fate to overtake the title track. Also, I think we need to give it time because their charting will improve

I've seen a LOT of people in Korea saying they didn't know it's G-Idle, they thought it's a new group. Even Western people said that. Saying this in the age of social media is crazy.

I honestly don't get why people are obsessed with Chart and especially Spotify. Like, it's the #1 platform where you can cheat with streams the most, other than YT. Not to mention, Spotify is made for like 5-6 Kpop groups, everyone else has decent or bad numbers.

i think the name change is irrelevant. the song is just bad

Quote from L-a-z-y

i think the name change is irrelevant. the song is just bad

Boooo!

Quote from David33

I've seen a LOT of people in Korea saying they didn't know it's G-Idle, they thought it's a new group. Even Western people said that. Saying this in the age of social media is crazy.

I honestly don't get why people are obsessed with Chart and especially Spotify. Like, it's the #1 platform where you can cheat with streams the most, other than YT. Not to mention, Spotify is made for like 5-6 Kpop groups, everyone else has decent or bad numbers.

I am confused that people are confused about the name change. They just dropped the "G", so it shouldn't be hard to figure out it's the same group.

Using spotify to measure Idle's success sounds like people trying to attack them. They were never a group that charted well globally like that. Out of the 4th gen group it's mainly NewJeans, Le Sserafim, and Aespa that charted well globally. Hybe groups will always have the advantage in that. Also, people shouldn't care that much and care more about the quality. The quality of the project is fine imo and they have solid b-sides, so we should be happy about that. Also, the group usually starts off slow imo when it comes to domestic charts

"Good Thing" by i-dle debuts with 375,185 streams on the Spotify counter.

Quote from David33

I've seen a LOT of people in Korea saying they didn't know it's G-Idle, they thought it's a new group. Even Western people said that. Saying this in the age of social media is crazy.

I honestly don't get why people are obsessed with Chart and especially Spotify. Like, it's the #1 platform where you can cheat with streams the most, other than YT. Not to mention, Spotify is made for like 5-6 Kpop groups, everyone else has decent or bad numbers.

GIDLE used to pull very decent numbers on spotify, just like IVE.