in terms of popularity which group is bigger invidually? Aespa or New jeans?

That's a difficult question. I'll say Aespa, but NJs popularity between the members is way more balanced than Aespa one.

IF i have to Rank

In korea

1. Karina

2.Hanni = winter

3. Minji = Haerin

4. Daniel= hyein

5. Ningning

6. Gisele

Internationally

1. Karina

2. Hanni

3. Winter

4. Minji= Haerin = Daniel = ningning( extremly popular in china)

5. Giselle = hyein

This is what i observe so i could be wrong.

1.Karina
2. Winter

2.5. Hanni

3. Haerin

4. Minji

4.5. Ningning

5. Danielle

6. Hyein/Giselle

Quote from Slayurfaves

interesting I would place Winter above hanni though Hanni is probably known for the hybe issue but other than that I don't think so I doubt she has a bigger indidual fandom in Korea or internationally

this year Hanni went super viral for her Tokyo dome performance and she's extremly well liked in korea. About Fandom, non of them have made solo debut yet so don't know how much their fandom will support them.

only thing i'm sure about is Karina being 1 and giselle being last.

Yama-Chan look what you started

Quote from Slayurfaves

sorry but I've always been curious about this anyways

you can vote and reply here too

I voted aespa for individually but as a group or brand I think they’re even in sea but NJ globally

Individual members? Aespa

From what I've seen on most googled, most youtube searched etc the ranking is something like

Karina

Hanni

Winter

Minji

Haerin

Ningning

Giselle

Danielle

Hyein

https://theqoo.net/square/3490869810

In Korea and internationally overall

1. Karina

2. Winter

3. Hanni

Then the rest(idk other njs members sorry)

In China

1. Karina

2. Ningning

3. Winter

4. Hanni

Then the rest

In Japan

1. Karina

2. Hanni

3. Giselle

Then the rest

Quote from Slayurfaves

We can always measure individual fandom though you don't have to release solos.

Don't stan them so don't know about their Individual fandom. About Hanni, i remember Yama-Chan posting about Hanni achievement and Her viral trend. There was a time people were doomposting about karina bcoz winter Eclipse her in popularity so i guess winter could be more popular than hanni.

I don't really care and never have.

All I know is that NewJeans as a group is substantially more popular, and that's all that matters to me.

By the way, I wouldn't recommend you try to go blow for blow with me. Your threads don't bother me in the slightest, but clearly mine have you feeling some type of way.

Couldn't come up with a credible argument in defense of your favorite declining group, so this is what you try instead

Blinks, you better come get this triggered fan.

aespa obviously

Quote from SooYoung

I know people are still stuck in 2021 was giselle was nobody and was picked last

but this year she really bloom and she gain a tons of new fans and her popularity with Whiplash have exploded

and "Giselle super time" went super viral in Japan and you can see it looking at the reactions

her part always gets tons of reaction from Fangirls

her "macbook selfie" are often viral on the kpop twitter for her hot attitude, now that she's more confident in being herself and finding her style people finally start to notice her

Display More

Whiplash was really Giselle's era.

It's great to see the love she's been getting recently. Or since Spicy really