best selling album by a girl group in Circle until now

It's not misleading, it's you didn't understand the chart given .

It's not misleading. You just don't understand it lol

Quote from Slayurfaves

how if they are adding their debut album ( that was last year + oricon sales ) shouldn't they say their cumulative sales since debut? it would be more accurate

still it's good to make a separate thread regardless from individual album sales ( not only cumulative sales) I haven't seen these kind of thread in a while

Like I said, you still didn't understand. Well number is not for everyone but I acknowledge your efforts

Your chart already has a very important mistake

Get Up has sold 1.6, if not 1.7 million copies. It overtakes The Album

Quote from Slayurfaves

how if they are adding their debut album ( that was last year + oricon sales ) shouldn't they say their cumulative sales since debut? it would be more accurate

Theyre adding the debut album because the debut album still puts up strong sales in 2023

I wouldn't give it much tought bc it's not like officka charts will count all that, gain yearly update just count sales per album

Quote from Slayurfaves

yeah but was last year it doesn't make sense how about the oricon sales? it's weird Japanese sales too

the chart captures all sales made by a group in a given calendar year

Edit: nvm

Quote from Slayurfaves

yeah but was last year it doesn't make sense how about the oricon sales? it's weird Japanese sales too

Here is the break down (I copy paste from Icaro_Ribeiro post from the other thread)

NJ sales are also calendar year only (2023)

Debut EP - Over 600k

OMG - 1,6kk

Get Up - 1,7kk (so far)

Oricon - 0

Hope it makes sense now

Born Pink sales are not updated 👀

Aespa also sold 2.2M