Is pointing the flaws of the group u stan openly makes u less of a stan/fan?

Quote from icyruios

It's all good you didn't say anything to make me upset.

Also, I didn't know you stanned Twice! Who's you're favorite member?

Let me make a thread and we'll see

Depends

Criticism is fine and all but its pretty irritating to see someone keep on critiquing their faves lmao like if the group gives u so much to complain abiut than u should unstan

Quote from icyruios

I always see myself choosing between Jihyo and Momo

Aww, they are amazing My bias is Jihyo, as you may be able to tell (and she's my ult) and I love Momo too! I support all members

Quote from atropos

I was talking about constructive criticism or pointing flaws out respectfully. The reaction seems to be the same like u dragged the group.

I was giving more my own point of view when I see a fan acting like that then speaking in general. Actually, It's hard to speak in general, because I don't think there's a consensus. No matter what you say or do, or how nice you are, there will be always someone to complain anyway, regardess of the fandom. But not even Jesus pleased everyone...

Quote from icyruios

She's so beautiful and cuteee omg

original (2).jpg

Also, I agree with your statement, I don't notice it as much here with Once but it's a lot worse on Twitter and IG than here.

To begin with there is way to criticize so of someone is bluntly shaming someone that's just hate, other than that if you don't like your faves songs, performance... You have the right to point out your opinion, you're the one who buys their album, concert tickets, goods etc ...so yeah you can criticize

Surround yourself with level headed people and this won't be a problem.

In the end, everything is flawed. I prefer to focus on the qualities instead.

But to respond to your question, I think it depends on what you consider 'flaws'. Their approach to music? Their chemistry as a team? Their image as idols? Tbh, these things are kinda subjective to me and what you might consider a flaw, someone else might consider a quality.

It's healthy to have disagreements. But imo, too much negativism and over-emphasis over someone's flaws might be a bit of a hassle.

It’s only certain fandoms that have devolved into a cult where only positive things are allowed to be said. Even wanting the artist to release different music or change their style is seen as negative or being an anti.