Is pointing the flaws of the group u stan openly makes u less of a stan/fan?
-
You're a fake if you criticize them. You're a fake if you praise them even when it's bad.
Thus, we're all fake.
You're not allowed to criticize because you're not a fan. If you're a fan you cannot criticize.
Thus, nobody can criticize.
-
yes kiss the feet of your faves
-
You're a fake if you criticize them. You're a fake if you praise them even when it's bad.
Thus, we're all fake.
The fandom u r part of will never call u fake tho if u praise them. If u criticize most probably they will.
-
Depends how you point it out tho. Many would rather just keep it to themself.
-
It doesn't.
I don't like Umpah Umpah's chorus and I don't like Rookie. Has my ReVeluv card been revoked? I don't think so.
Fandoms are too overprotective over their idols.
-
In this forum, yes.
Especially if you are an ARMY/Blink/Once
-
Does it?
If u do that the fandom will most probably call u a fake no matter what.
Honestly I do not think so I think it makes you a better fan as you are willing to admit they are not perfect but enjoy them anyways.
-
Depends on the fandom really.. I find orbits tolerant towards criticism. I notice orbits I follow don’t get “called out” for disliking songs or discussing members lack of talents. The opposite are blinks they will have a meltdown if anything remotely resemble criticism are thrown the girls way. Example: I really hope jisoo will act well in the drama. blinks/solo stans: you fake ot4 you never had faith in her you the ones calling her stiff talentless in the beginning. jisoo has no one in this fandom!! ( based on true story)
-
LMFAO OMG this is a heavy question. Hits a little too close to home but no, that should never be the case. It just means you’re not a blind follower of said artist and are level headed if there’s certain things you want to criticize or call out.
Of course, the reactions on this website though... as if you’re committing a sin and your fan status needs to be revoked.
End of the day, you don’t need validation from anyone or their fandom. You do you!
-
-
In this forum, yes.
Especially if you are an ARMY/Blink/Once
Me being all of those...
Def for Army and blink but Once are more chill. We just share our opinions in the Once cult and since I'm good friends with 90% of the members, we talk about things that bother us...I have a few Once friends who I can talk about that to unless it's openly hating a member.
-
In this forum, yes.
Especially if you are an ARMY/Blink/Once
This
-
Me being all of those...
Def for Army and blink but Once are more chill. We just share our opinions in the Once cult and since I'm good friends with 90% of the members, we talk about things that bother us...I have a few Once friends who I can talk about that to unless it's openly hating a member.
Bish I'm in all of those too, just that I don't exactly seem like I'm with the flock among the 3 fanbase here. Because I feel if I say anything negative about them, people here will instantly revoke my fan status
I literally have the stats to back up my stan status but I'm sure people will still call me a fake fan if I ever say anything negative and say I'm token stanning them
-
Depends on how they are sharing this opinion. If It's construtive criticism, because you genuinely want them to improve or because you are just frustated for knowing their potention and expecting more, I see nothing wrong. If It's hateful, then yeah, I would not see this person as fan.
-
Depends how you point it out tho. Many would rather just keep it to themself.
Even if u say it in the most respectful manner there will be backlash. So is there a right way to go about this?
-
Bish I'm in all of those too, just that I don't exactly seem like I'm with the flock among the 3 fanbase here. Because I feel if I say anything negative about them, people here will instantly revoke my fan status
I literally have the stats to back up my stan status but I'm sure people will still call me a fake fan if I ever say anything negative and say I'm token stanning them
Aww I feel so bad. If you have anything to talk about, I'm your girl. But sorry if I made you feel upset, friend. That wasn't my intention
I didn't mean that you weren't a stan of all of them tho, I was just saying
-
It's perfectly fine to point out flaws and issues with a group even if you're a huge fan. Love and support should never be blind. I'm sure there are plenty of people who will call you a fake fan, but that's an issue for them and not you. You'll get a lot of "how dare you throw them under the bus" but that is only applicable if you full on drag them.
-
Aww I feel so bad. If you have anything to talk about, I'm your girl. But sorry if I made you feel upset, friend. That wasn't my intention
It's all good you didn't say anything to make me upset.
-
In this forum, yes.
Especially if you are an ARMY/Blink/Once
Onces ain't powerful in this forum. Most left. Army and blinks i agree.
-
imho no! everyone have the right to criticize as fans with good intentions and being realistic, it all depends in how they do it, sometimes someone pretends to be fans and start pointing flaws with malice intent we all can see that, but it's not the fans fault that sometimes there are too many antis? anyways in the end of the day it all comes to the way you point and criticize then you can tell the difference between a fan and a troll
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
