NING NING VS SULLYOON

Both are better singer than anyone who’s in Itflop

Quote from keyboardwarrior7

Doesn't sound bad, but I don't think the videos you posted did her justice vocally.

I went into this thinking Ning Ning was the better vocalist, but listening to the videos you posted makes me 2nd guess myself.

I'll have to listen to Winter live because now I'm wondering why Ning Ning is the main vocal and not Winter.

So more videos of Ningning singing. I think that she is better than Winter and Sullyoon though I love them both as singers.

Quote from Eldeweiss

So more videos of Ningning singing. I think that she is better than Winter and Sullyoon though I love them both as singers.

External Content youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Oh, okay. Yeah, she definitely has a better range than Sullyoon and better support. She makes hitting those higher notes seem effortless.

I prefer Sullyoon's vocal color and lower register sonically, but as far as being a vocalist overall (technique, support, range), Ning Ning seems to be better.

How did listening to Sullyeon sing made you think of Ningning? What a weird obsession. I would understand if you heard a song Ningning sang before and made the comparison or compared Ningning with Lily or Haewon.

It’s entirely your opinion to like one voice more than the other (I also like Sullyeon’s) but technically ie objectively she isn’t.

Off Topic:

The Ningning underrating in this thread is why SM should promote aespa’s vocals more. Like do more serious covers in singing shows/videos with clear audio like this to remind gold fish Kpop fans that they can sing. Also it’s funny aespa is ridiculed for not singing live in comparison threads like these yet the videos of aespa that MYs use to compare are raw unedited videos like RAW behind the scenes recording, raw radio singing, and singing in interviews.

AAhyeon

i think ning is better technically but i prefer sullyoon's tone more

Quote from K-PL

NingNing is better than Lily. Lily can only sing loud, which doesn't matter in the 21st century sing now there are microphones.

lol this one is delusional

Ning ning is better singer but sully is very talented with a face like a goddess

Quote from Haolat

shouldn't it be Ning vs Lily (Lily for me)

same or ning ning vs haewon (haewon)

ning ning vs sullyoon its ning ning

Quote from vivaliberta

no actually there re ton vocal coachs said lily is better than ningning.

Ningnin is still nasal vocalist and can't support C5 all time...

Being able to sing higher notes does not make you a better singer. Pavarotti would be a below average singer if that was the case. Lily just is loud, which is great if the microphone system ever dies, but otherwise is very 1 dimensional.

Vocal coach : The return

Nings

Quote from QueenMaknae27

AAhyeon

sullyoon is better singer than her

Quote from K-PL

Being able to sing higher notes does not make you a better singer. Pavarotti would be a below average singer if that was the case. Lily just is loud, which is great if the microphone system ever dies, but otherwise is very 1 dimensional.

delusional she isn’t just loud

Winter's vocals are annoying tbh. It sounds whiny high pitch.

Quote from K-PL

Being able to sing higher notes does not make you a better singer. Pavarotti would be a below average singer if that was the case. Lily just is loud, which is great if the microphone system ever dies, but otherwise is very 1 dimensional.

You're wrong. She isn't one dimensional and not just loud...lol...go look at the reviews from vocal coaches. She is the best 4th gen gg vocalist.