or do we love the complex, difficult choreo and focus on performance?
Does 4th gen focus too much on dance and visuals?
-
replace the word dance to visuals...then yes!
-
replace the word dance to visuals...then yes!
Oh yes, that too! Has 4th gen basically become models and dancers? Where are the vocals?
-
MissBehave
Changed the title of the thread from “Does 4th gen focus too much on dance?” to “Does 4th gen focus too much on dance and visuals?”. -
we love the complex, difficult choreo and focus on performance
this exactly. most vocal groups in the 4th gen are pretty nugu
-
what dance
2018-19 groups were significantly better dancers
-
Pretty much. I sorta dislike it cause alot of these 4th gen songs could sound alot better with a great vocalist.
-
Kpop fans complain about the lack of vocals but are a fan of groups that don't have vocals even in 3rd gen. If it's just to make debates to clear your conscience each time to end with conclusions like "I attach importance to voice colors and different tones, music is the most important for me"
Company just give you what you want. Look at the most popular group in 3rd gen, company just give what fans want.
-
Oh yes, that too! Has 4th gen basically become models and dancers? Where are the vocals?
I can't see the dance part, maybe because I only care for GGs but I don't see 4th gen being more focused in dance at all
-
Well, when building a commodity product vocals are rare and expensive - but dance can be taught, and visuals come out of a bottle.
-
this exactly. most vocal groups in the 4th gen are pretty nugu
Is this the way we prefer it?
-
-
-
what dance
2018-19 groups were significantly better dancers
isn't that the start of 4th gen?
-
Pretty much. I sorta dislike it cause alot of these 4th gen songs could sound alot better with a great vocalist.
Would you be willing to give up some of the choreo and the visuals to get better vocals?
-
Kpop fans complain about the lack of vocals but are a fan of groups that don't have vocals even in 3rd gen. If it's just to make debates to clear your conscience each time to end with conclusions like "I attach importance to voice colors and different tones, music is the most important for me"
Company just give you what you want. Look at the most popular group in 3rd gen, company just give what fans want.
Fans aren't a monolith though. People who stan 3rd gen groups that lack vocals pbly aren't the same people who lament the lack of vocals in 4th gen.
-
-
Well, when building a commodity product vocals are rare and expensive - but dance can be taught, and visuals come out of a bottle.
True, it's much harder to find and cultivate vocals than dance and beauty.
-
Yep, us multis can have it all!
(Though maybe not at the same time lol)
-
-
-
Yep, us multis can have it all!
(Though maybe not at the same time lol)
well i think some groups have it all...but that's because i'm biased like that lol
-
-
Fans aren't a monolith though. People who stan 3rd gen groups that lack vocals pbly aren't the same people who lament the lack of vocals in 4th gen.
Where did i say in my post fans are a monolith ? "Look at the most popular group in 3rd gen, company just give what fans want."
Most popular group = with the most fans = making money = other company try to do the same
Fans of vocals group = minority = less fans = making less money = other company don't do the same
It was like that for the 3rd gen, it's the same for the 4th gen.
-
-
-
-
-
Lol i love that guy
-
well i think some groups have it all...but that's because i'm biased like that lol
I don't stan any 4th gen groups but i think my faves have it all too
-
Display More
Where did i say in my post fans are a monolith ? "Look at the most popular group in 3rd gen, company just give what fans want."
Most popular group = with the most fans = making money = other company try to do the same
Fans of vocals group = minority = less fans = making less money = other company don't do the same
It was like that for the 3rd gen, it's the same for the 4th gen.
True, based on sales, most kpop fans don't seem to mind not having good vocals
-
I feel like that’s the same for every gen tho 😭
Good thing we stan a 3rd gen group that isn't like that
-
-
-
I could see this. Everyone wants a part in their choreo that everyone get learn and do cutely for tiktok. I hate it here
-
Good thing we stan a 3rd gen group that isn't like that
Yesssss
-
-
I haven't stanned Xeed. I'm just flirting...
-
-
Visuals is what sells, so yeah, they have to.
-
as long as they don't completely ignore music quality, i don't mind
-
Visuals is what sells, so yeah, they have to.
Isn't it weird though that visuals are so important to a music career?
-
-
Isn't it weird though that visuals are so important to a music career?
visual is always important for an idol career
Most popular members in a group are usually visual...
I mean even non-visual members are beautiful .............
that's how always works
if people really want talents as they said, many nugu groups should have been popular lol
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
