Posts by Spsnowflakes

Eh, RV have a pretty hot scandal during their hiatus tho. Who knows how much it truly affect their initial charting performance.

I don't think their next album will be in Sept at this point.

Quote from neigl

As fearless i liked you post and looking at gaon points i would agree for the musical part. but since it said most popular i guess that one still goes to Blackpink.

well op is f(x) stan so yeah, i had the same tought...

I only said that cause OP never put Bigbang on the list unless they made a comeback in that particular year. So I think the same rule should be applied to 2021 as well.

For 2021 since BP didn't have any comeback this year so far. I'll probably replace them with Brave Girls tbh.

Also f(x) for 2012 is a bit....

For 2017 I'll def put BTS, apart from digital & physical sales, they've won more Daesang as well for 2017.

Acts with most Daesang for 2017 (only counting KMA, SMA, MAMA, GDA, MMA):

BTS (5), EXO/IU (2), TWICE/Hyukoh/Kang Tae Gu (1).

Shinee-Replay

Miss A-Bad Girl Good Girl

Jungkook Dope

Who's 1st, G.O.D?

Quote from Zenning

Seeing how Red Velvet debuted in 2014 at the start of August and that contracts since 2010 can't last longer than 7 years, this would suggest that they've already renewed their contracts, all of them

I thought Yeri joined RV in 2015 tho?

For BTS, it's more surprising how 'Dynamite' is above some of the biggest songs of 2021 aka IU 'Celebrity' and 'Lilac' on Melon right now.

Quote from jenniesbtch

Also, I wonder how different these lists would be if it was only views within the year of release.

Quote from daniel-cruz

That's what i am thinking too.

There must be a video for it on youtube.

This one is for BoyGroup

Edit-Top 3 from each year (2015-2020):

Quote from FSXP

It meant your tracks would flood the charts on the release of a mini or album.

If that's the criteria, then you should add AKMU as well (at least acc to their latest album chart performance). Also, NCT Dream manage to charted some of their Bside in Top100 Melon 24 Chart, so with that criteria maybe they're a semi-digimon after all? Lol

Quote from z1

Imo Ice Cream basically shows why Blackpink is a digimon.

Unpromoted, english song and managed to reach #6 when everyone else is underperforming in 24hits.

If you think because of that they arent digimon, then even Twice, Epik High etc are all not digimons. Which is definitely not true in korea

My main point was even BP need a quality songs to do well on chart, since the person I quoted said "a true digimon shouldn't rely on the quality of the songs to do well on chart" but then he/she mentioned BP, so I just point out that in my opinion BP have their not too well moment on chart with Ice Cream (at least compared to a digimons above their level like IU, BTS, etc who can release a pure garbage song and it'll chart inside top 10 for a few weeks probably). Now, if some ppl think Ice Cream were doing well on chart then thats no problem.

Quote from WhimsyLand

To be fair, if any other group would've released that song, it wouldn't even had made it to the top 20

Not really, if it's an "actual" digimon, maybe like BTS or IU, I bet it can stay inside top 10 for at least a week

Quote from WhimsyLand

I don't think anyone calls iKon, Winner, or BTOB digital monsters anymore.

I think groups who heavily depend on music show performances/song quality to do well on charts (like Itzy, RV) can't be called digital monsters. True digimons don't need either of those things for a successful comeback.

I also don't think Taeyeon is a digital monster, if she counts here.

I also think we should stop calling Epik High digital monsters. Their previous album and single with Colde under-performed.

Only true digimons for me now are - IU, BTS, BP, Jang Beomjune. Nobody else has their consistency.

Display More

Imo BP-Ice Cream didn't do that well on chart tho. Peaked at #6 on Melon for a few hours only before it started to fall outside top 10. So I think even for BP, they still depend on a song quality to do well on chart.

Also, might be off topic but, group who I think were a digimon but never get enough credit:

Miss A

Quote from MassiveKpopFan

I think they were, Mr. Mr. was a stumbling block but Party and Lion Heart did well. Holiday did meh.

Iirc Party and Lion Heart ranked at #44 and #59 on Gaon Year End Digital Chart, personally I won't call it "well" enough for an act who were supposed to have a digimon status.

SNSD?

Both weren't that popular internationally to begin with, even in the "traditional" international Kpop market like Japan and SEA, I don't think they were doing that well. While BTS seems to have a decent international followers even when they were still "nugu" in Korea, they already tour in an Arena in some SEA countries in 2014 iirc.

Thats the biggest plot twist I've ever seen in Kpop