Posts by Spsnowflakes

Quote from Yunathehomegirl

I think it's either Gee, like you said, or Wonder Girls' Nobody

Quote from MassiveKpopFan

It's a 3 way tie between Gee, Lies, and Nobody.

Honorable mentions: Last Farewell, Haru Haru, Sorry Sorry, Fire, Fiction.

Somehow I always thought 'Tell Me' is bigger than 'Nobody' in Korea. Also if you mention 'Fiction', I think you def should mention WG-So Hot as well (It's no #10 on Melon decade chart).

Quote from atropos

Well exceptions exist but they weren't the biggest 2nd gen group of SM. And i don't think we can equate exo's and suju's fandom as exo has way more sales. But yes for 2nd gen group they had one of the biggest fandoms.

SJ at peak & pre-2015 EXO (before rivalry with BTS come around lol) have similar sales per album imo, around 300k+ (if we are not combining Repack and Chinese ver)

Hmmm, Super Junior got really big in their 4th year tho, with Sorry Sorry. Imo SJ at their peak (fandom wise at least) are at the same level as EXO.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Only 8 true GG songs in 9 months since that chart began, plus 2 GG songs that were released in the Stone Age and one temporary GG project song. Add in all the Kpop boy group songs (Dyna and LGO) and you basically have 10 Kpop group songs that have made it in the top 10 of Melon in 9 months. That's legit terrible. Kpop groups deserve way better than this from Korea.

+ Savage Love (BTS Remix)

In general, I feel like it's BTS > K-Drama > Kpop (w/o BTS) tbh.

Quote from CherrySoda

False. BTS took off in Korea because they were surprised by their huge fandom internationally. Ateez is kind of benefiting from that too.

Hmm In 2015 'I Need U', managed to enter top 100 Gaon Digital Chart, the only other BG that manage to enter the 2015 digital chart are all big/trendy names in Korea (Bigbang, EXO, Ikon, Shinee). The song also debuted at no #2 on Melon old realtime chart. So I'll prob consider BTS as a B-Tier BG in Korea at least, and thats before they blow up internationally.

Quote from MrAkimo123

If it GDA, they might have a chance at least a nomination since I think it is 100% based on digital sales/performance. The others award involve voting & album sales, which the group will lose to others with a strong fanbase.

I thought old song can't win on GDA? Or any year end award show really. Rollin is an old song right?