It is safe to say that Suga is one of the most successful idol producers

Genius

jayz.gif

Quote from kpopnewbie32

Yes he is. Now if only big hit let him produce a BTS title track - been waiting since 2017

Definitely yes, at least for now. It's even more correctly to write 'the most successful korean producer', cause even said Teddy, despite of countless hits, hasn't composed for western acts and definitely nobody writes 'prod of' with a name of any other producer in the title of song to grab attention. Being in BTS really gave a lot of favors and benefits to Yoongi, he indeed got what he came to bighit for.

It can be said that he is the smartest producer and not the most successful because he chooses to produce songs for already big artists and the success of their songs is expected, whether he is the one who produced them or others he play save 😭😭😭

And in the end, we can't say that he is the most successful idol product while GD and Zico exist, that he can't compare to them at all

And if he was a successful producer like his fans claim why wouldn't Hype let him produce for his group albums, and why did his own songs fail on the Korean chart?

https://www.allkpop.com/article/2022/03/bigbangs-g-dragon-and-iu-are-the-only-idols-ranked-as-the-wealthiest-celebrities-from-copyright-royalties-in-south-korea

yes

Well, in general it would be "unsafe" to say anything uncomplimentary about BTS

But "one of the", sure.

At this point, any member of BTS could release anything and it will get hyped up, far beyond any other release.

There can be no objective assessment, in already a subjective field.

So we will have to wait until the BTS craze fades and then whether he can succeed as a producer for acts to come in the future.

As yet the only idol who got a KOMCA Daesang is G-Dragon, that can be the next target for Suga to achieve.

And then we have Blueberry Eyes outside of Korea too. He's so good at his job.

Quote from Sdvip

And in the end, we can't say that he is the most successful idol product

The title says "one of". Your whole comment you typed was pointless.

Quote from Sdvip

It can be said that he is the smartest producer and not the most successful because he chooses to produce songs for already big artists and the success of their songs is expected, whether he is the one who produced them or others he play save 😭😭😭

And in the end, we can't say that he is the most successful idol product while GD and Zico exist, that he can't compare to them at all

And if he was a successful producer like his fans claim why wouldn't Hype let him produce for his group albums, and why did his own songs fail on the Korean chart?

https://www.allkpop.com/articl…-royalties-in-south-korea

Suran was a small indie act when her song, WINE produced by SUGA topped the Korean charts. It remains her biggest and only hit song to this day.

And it makes no sense to claim that SUGA did not produce a song based on…fan rivalry and ‘Dude, trust me’ when YG acts including your faves had Teddy’s signature sound all over their tracks.

He was already producing for BTS’ albums before he branched out to other artists, domestically and internationally.

If you’re asking why his own solo songs didn’t chart in Korea, it’s because they’re from his mixtapes (not official promoted albums) that weren’t published on Melon and other Korean charts. K-fans could only access Agust D’s tracklist from SoundCloud and YouTube.

I advise you to stop pulling things out of your ass the next time you want to downplay or argue about a group you don’t even like.

Quote from Sdvip

It can be said that he is the smartest producer and not the most successful because he chooses to produce songs for already big artists and the success of their songs is expected, whether he is the one who produced them or others he play save 😭😭😭

And in the end, we can't say that he is the most successful idol product while GD and Zico exist, that he can't compare to them at all

And if he was a successful producer like his fans claim why wouldn't Hype let him produce for his group albums, and why did his own songs fail on the Korean chart?

https://www.allkpop.com/articl…-royalties-in-south-korea

Sigh.. you really made an alt account to spew this nonsense. His first major hit was a song produced for Suran - she is not a big artist and she certainly was not when he made wine for her... so that negates your point.

Also his mixtapes/songs were not even available to chart in korea since they are free mix tapes and the quality of the work speaks for itself regardless of charting.