Do we really want equal line distribution?

Winwin is in charge for being cute

That's a lot of hard work already

Quote from Weitangent

Even when looking at groups where the members are all vocally talented, like mamamoo and aespa, there is still no perfect line distribution. And it is an ideal that kpop Stans should not be even trying to pursue, since singing ability does not equate to having the right vocal tone that complements the song best.

And more popularly, asking for more lines, I know it’s extremely difficult seeing your bias in a particular group having basically zero lines, especially for larger groups, I Stan winwin ( that has at most 5 seconds of just saying alr alr) but you also have to admit that not all members are equally capable, and if winwin sang 39% of a song, it will not be enjoyable at all. I am sorry but my boy can’t sing, and it’s time we move on and accept that.

Agreed but I actually like Winwin's voice

not equal, but fair

Like this is good enough

This is not fair for E:U

Quote from Weitangent

Unfortunately don’t follow them, but is it not because her vocal tone doesn’t complement the song, seeing as how the concepts are quite different.

I saw that her position is main rapper and dancer. So for the concept it just makes sense for her to not get as much lines, no?

It was just example . It is not real comeback, but in every song every member should at least get 10+ seconds.

I don't want an equal line distribution but a fair line distribution. The hardest lines should go to the members who have the skills to deal with it. On the other side sometimes the main vocalist sings more than half the song alone when some lines are easy to sing and could go to someone else.

I remember Camila getting so much hate for getting more lines than the other members. If it was kpop, the hate wouldn't be half as bad. in general kpop stans are more chill if it comes to line distribution, but I agree equal line distribution doesn't make sense.

Perfectly equally is near impossible. But I do agree with the distribution should be fair. Not like a few seconds for someone then and having the main vocalist carrying near everything.

Quote from Eldeweiss

I don't want an equal line distribution but a fair line distribution. The hardest lines should go to the members who have the skills to deal with it. On the other side sometimes the main vocalist sings more than half the song alone when some lines are easy to sing and could go to someone else.

Agreed.

That's why my ideal group are groups where the members actually have something to offer (either singing, rap, dance, or being attractive on center), that way everyone can shine equally regardless of of line distribution. Of course this can only be achieved if the group has good teamwork, that way they can help each other shine.

Nobody wants to acknowledge that their faves simply dont have singing/rapping talent. In some groups it is very clear why the line distribution is unequal e.g everglow. It irritates me when their fans give Mia a hard time as their line distribution while unequal is fair.

In contrast - the line distribution for recent BTS songs makes sense but older fans like myself cant help but find it disappointing when rapline (hope/suga) gets 7 seconds each in a title track (I haven't been paying close attention this year so I don't know if this was the case for universe)... In their case given the musical direction to more vocal based pop it makes sense but also feels like a waste since the rapping is what the group excels at (vocal line is just okay/competent).