lmao thanks more then anything I wonder who will get kma noms this year? Idk if even bts is a sure in this time around

You should post that on twitter lol I think everyone here is aware about the criteria

Thank you for posting this. Very helpful

"A guide for dummies who cry every year when BTS win" is my favourite part of this thread. It's honestly so annoying when people are like "so and so should have got it" and "give someone other than BTS a chance". Maybe promote your faves ARMYs are such a strong fandom and we get it done in terms of sales for our boys. They started from the bottom and now topping the charts easily

I probably won't need this since my faves probably won't be there

wait maybe KD will be there

What's the eligibility period?

criteria for the made up SMA digital daesang in 2019 = money

biggest flex is bts winning sma and kma daesangs without attending. kpoppies can't cry "oh my faves will not attend so they won't win"

Quote from ripia

why should judges get 40? How is their opinion greater than the GP? Makes no sense.

The judges are more than likely connected to the industry. Their opinion should be held to a high standard. And there's still 60% criteria not by judges. Anyways, anticipate BTS's next Daesang

Lemme save the graphic right quick

Quote from MassiveKpopFan

Lemme save the graphic right quick

We'll need that for later

Quote from ripia

Still tho people say music is subjective.

So why should a few peoples opinion outweigh 100s of thousands of civilians.

Nothing to do with bts btw im just speaking in general. They should be 20% to me.

Because everyone is just gonna vote for their faves regardless of record sales or impact on the industry. The judges would be more objective

Quote from Golden_Wishes

What's the eligibility period?

Some shows change it year by year, so I'm assuming that's why it's not present on the graphic.

Not exactly true. Every year Oscar voters anonymously tell newspapers how they vote for Oscars: because they think the actor deserve it after a long career, because they seem like a nice person, because prominent critics like the film or the actor. A lot of people voting for the Academy Awards admit they haven’t seem all the movies nominated. There is no fair award show judging.

Quote from ripia

why should judges get 40? How is their opinion greater than the GP? Makes no sense.

Public (read fandom) voting is the one that makes zero sense

Quote from ripia

so they judge through indutry success i think they judge their personal opinion?

It would be rigged if it was a personal opinion, so that's not the case

Quote from ripia

so they judge through indutry success i think they judge their personal opinion?

They judge based on [undisclosed] and give [undisclosed] points for each contender

Quote from paradis

Not always undisclosed, for instance GDA reveal their Judges score

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Well that was kind of a landslide

Quote from merribelle

Well that was kind of a landslide

That's cause BTS is in their own league

That BTS could pull those numbers with a song that came out so late in the year. True Kings

Quote from paradis

Not always undisclosed, for instance GDA reveal their Judges score

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

After all these years, it was the only time they did, did it only for 3 songs and still no criteria. None of the other awards released their judging score.

The fact that Meteor, the #3 song in digital points, did not win one of the 10 Digital Bonsangs already makes GDA very questionable.

Quote from paradis

Yes and still BTS did not win and no Army threw a tantrum.

That's because we're a very mature fandom. Some need to take notes

Quote from paradis

2019 too

IMG_20211018_081116.jpg

Only one song, that tells nothing

wtf2.gif

Quote from paradis

The reason BTS win is cause they score high in all 3 categories - digitals/sales, fan votes and judges votes.

The sooner people realise this the better they will be able to cope with BTS winning daesangs every year over their more "deserving" faves.

I completely agree! You want your faves to win, start actually contributing to sales and promoting your faves, and stream their songs People need to stop being jealous of BTS, they earned their spot fair and square!

Kpoppies are embarassing lmao .

I love ur effort to spread facts OP but anticipate their meltdowns all over this site when BTS wins daesangs cuz their "faves" make "quality" music only they can appreciate.

Quote from a_song_calling_f

Kpoppies are embarassing lmao .

I love ur effort to spread facts OP but anticipate their meltdowns all over this site when BTS wins daesangs cuz their "faves" make "quality" music only they can appreciate.

I'm literally expecting meltdowns It'll be funny to watch people complain while they sat back and did nothing to contribute to sales

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

wtf2.gif

And there it is ladies and gentleman the blinks have arrived

Tru tru

Thanks OP. I'm ready to revive this thread when the crying threads happen later