NINGNING DID A PREDEBUT DUET WITH THE GP999 VOCAL TRAINER!

OMG, is it for SMROOKIES content?

I believe this is one of shinning stars animation songs in Chinese. I forgot the name, but I think the korean one is better.

Quote from SendFoodPics

yeah the korean one with koeun has better mixing I just found it funny because this is the first time I've actually heard him sing.

Oh shit, how old is this coach now? I believe this is around 3 to 4 years ago. So NingNing was around 16?

Quote from SendFoodPics

I think 15? He's 32 now.

So he was 28. This song was produced with korean lyrics in mind, so singing re-written Chinese kinda made it awkward even for NingNing.

Did you see that Reflection clip from her livestream yesterday shes so effortless

No offense to Winter, but Ningning is clearly the main vocal of Aespa for me.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

No offense to Winter, but Ningning is clearly the main vocal of Aespa for me.

It always has been this way. There is no offense. Winter is a competent singer, but in aespa she is not the main vocal. If you listen to aespa albums, especially the title track. Ningning is responsible for most difficult part. She is the more capable singer.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

No offense to Winter, but Ningning is clearly the main vocal of Aespa for me.

Ningning IS the main vocalist in aespa.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

No offense to Winter, but Ningning is clearly the main vocal of Aespa for me.

No one said otherwise. I mean they said aespa has no assigned roles because they’re all all-rounders to an extent but they also said Ningning is their main vocal.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

No offense to Winter, but Ningning is clearly the main vocal of Aespa for me.

This was what I was trying to explain in a pervious thread Winter is a impressive vocalist but not near Ningning’s level not now at least but I’m sure all members will improve overtime. SM idols always improve vocally after debut :shyy:

Ningning has an incredible voice

Imaging her improvement now lmaooo and people said Aespa are vocally weak lmaoo I smell Aeskarma