Karina vs Ningning vs Winter who did the line best?

Ningning for me she was most clearest but Winter and Karina are also perfect too

Winter!!

Quote from Yumeku

I time stamped a little earlier but basically, the line starts when Karina starts singing "I am a savage" then Winter repeats the same line

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

and here is Ningning doing the same line

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

I like all but I just love the way Winter sings. She has so much fighting attitude.

Display More

Do you have some sort of MR removed for this video? It's a perfect example of an above average vs an average vs a weak-to-average. I want to use it.

Personally tone wise it's Winter but technique wise it's Ningning!

Winter, after listening to it a 100 times, it's my favorite part

all

I loved all of them

If we're talking about the "ohhh" though, I personally liked Karina's the most

Quote from Yumeku

I don't unfortunately. But didn't know Ningning is considered above-average already! wow my girl is following my SNSD favs footsteps.

she's my perfect example of a border, we need to hear the head voice (she's really SNSD Seohyun rn and debut Jessica which is wild!) Winter reminds me of Sunny....oh what could have been. I know Sunny doesn't want to sing anymore but I'm sad :((

Ningning and Monday are vocal besties they better meet up and both sing

Why no love for Giselle?

Technically I'd choose Ningning followed by Winter. But, oddly enough, I find Karina's fuller sound the most satisfying out of the three. On a completely biased standpoint, I'd choose Karina.

Quote from whorerwin

I loved all of them

If we're talking about the "ohhh" though, I personally liked Karina's the most

Yeah, me too.

There's something about her singing it that is just really attractive vocally. It's really clean?

Winter and Ning Ning are just pure power though.

ningning

winter weirds me out

NN but I'm biased

I won't lie... Winter's lines are always the highlight of all Aespa's tt's so far. For me.

Ningning is more impactful for me

karina for me

Winter for me because she gives power to that line and makes the song even more impactful.

let's be objective, Winter did it the best

Another reason why she often has more lines than Ningning the official main vocal because her vocal is no joke while the execution is perfect