Karina vs Ningning vs Winter who did the line best?

Winter ❄️

Ningning for me

They all doing it well. NingNing is my bias but I will go with Winter. She put the right energy into it.

Even though her isnt as clear as others, I love the way Karina does it, her voice has a lot of volume which just makes it sound the best to me

Ningning

Quote from gerrard174

let's be objective, Winter did it the best

Another reason why she often has more lines than Ningning the official main vocal because her vocal is no joke while the execution is perfect

Don't lead vocalists usually get more/as much lines as the main vocalists though

NN

winter imo.

Quote from reesul29

Don't lead vocalists usually get more/as much lines as the main vocalists though

Not in general, But noticed this trend in many of SM ggs and Twice

- in f(x) Krystal generally has more lines than Luna

- in RV, Seulgi has more lines than Wendy

- Twice, nayeon more lines than Jihyo

Not counting those groups where lead vocals which are taking rapper role as well e.g. Blackpink

In most groups, usually vocals are hardcarried by main vocals e.g. OMG, AOA, Girls Day ...

Quote from gerrard174

Not in general, But noticed this trend in many of SM ggs and Twice

- in f(x) Krystal generally has more lines than Luna

- in RV, Seulgi has more lines than Wendy

- Twice, nayeon more lines than Jihyo

Not counting those groups where lead vocals which are taking rapper role as well e.g. Blackpink

In most groups, usually vocals are hardcarried by main vocals e.g. OMG, AOA, Girls Day ...

Display More

Interesting

Ning Ning but honestly winter sounds so good its hard to pick but ning ning because of the last part where should sang that high note