Yonhap News Agency about Top 10 KPop GG's of all time

Quote from icyruios

I would put Sistar/Kara/Wonder Girls instead of Apink/(G)I-DLE/ITZY but that's just me

Not just you, i'd think everyone. I don't feel like any of the last 4 mentioned deserve to be there when you have whole Sistar, T-ara, Kara and WG.

I mean, do Itzy and Gidle really deserve to be there over say S.E.S who were the first formal gg in Korea (and without whom none of these others would exist)?

They probably aimed at putting groups from different eras, hence (G)I-DLE and ITZY. I think they also favored groups that are still relevant today hence the lack of 1st gen and practically any disbanded group.

Quote from Alex_Murphy

They probably aimed at putting groups from different eras, hence (G)I-DLE and ITZY. I think they also favored groups that are still relevant today hence the lack of 1st gen and practically any disbanded group.

I was just about to say that the ranking only makes sense if they were doing it based on eras and who's still active. Otherwise it's a bit weird.

Replace apink/gf/gifle/itzy with finkl/ses/wg/kara

interesting

S.E.S definitely deserve to be there no matter what. Their songs get covered basically every year at year end shows

Quote from WhimsyLand

I mean, do Itzy and Gidle really deserve to be there over say S.E.S who were the first formal gg in Korea (and without whom none of these others would exist)?

I've learned that all-time in Kpop means 2nd and 3rd gen only.

Blackpink

Twice

Mamamoo

Girls' Generation

2NE1

Red Velvet

Apink

GFriend

(G)I-dle

Itzy

This list cannot be taken seriously, as apparently the author of the video has no knowledge of the First Generation. Also, it is far too soon to place any Fourth Generation groups in the top 10. Here's a more accurate selection of the top 10 girl groups of all-time:

• S.E.S. (1997)

• Fin.K.L (1998)

• Wonder Girls (2007)

• Kara (2007)

• Girls' Generation (2007)

• 2NE1 (2009)

• Sistar (2010)

• Red Velvet (2014)

• Twice (2015)

• Blackpink (2016)

I’m glad people are bringing up Fin.KL & SES. I-fans seem to forget about 1st Gen, which is kinda understandable when most of us got into it during the 2nd Gen, but still it’s important to know who started it all

Baby Vox is another 1st Gen GG I’d add to this list. They were the holy trinity with Fin.KL & SES

The Twice description is lame af. This is a GG that’s the biggest selling Korean female artist ever, won the most Daesangs, became the first to have a Dome Tour, and more

And THAT’S what they used for Twice

I feel snsd, twice, f(x), 2ne1, blackpink, s.e.s, wonder girls, sistar, gidle/Aespa/itzy would be better

Edit: Miss A!!! How could I forget miss a with their monster rookie debut and when their songs are still covered. My apologies.

Quote from Lubby00

The Twice description is lame af. This is a GG that’s the biggest selling Korean female artist ever, won the most Daesangs, became the first to have a Dome Tour, and more

And THAT’S what they used for Twice

ikr.