MARIAAAAA AVE MARIAAAA
this is also Aespa main vocal 
Aespa have 4 main vocal :P
see! we knew the girls can sing! now sm needs to let them perform black mamba, forever, and next level live! they don't need the lip sync but sm seems obsessed these days
see! we knew the girls can sing! now sm needs to let them perform black mamba, forever, and next level live! they don't need the lip sync but sm seems obsessed these days
this is not lip sync '-'
this is not lip sync '-'
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
those are LAR (pre-recorded vocals), yes it is lip sync lol. aespa have yet to have a live stage, but like I said in my OP i don't think it's cause they can't I just think SM is being weird about letting them sing
Watch this
Even Ningning said they sing live there. It's just that sm edited it to sound perfect.
and that's when you prove that you can't even make the difference between lip sync and real live
I'm so embarass for you :-D:-D:-D:-D
i especially took this performance as a proof because i knew that you couldn't even make the difference and just wanted to shit on Aespa performance
too bad for you that SM drop the behind the scene of this performance, and the girls were singing live 
Watch this
External Content youtu.beContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.Even Ningning said they sing live there. It's just that sm edited it to sound perfect.
i'm so emabrass for this fake people
that's why i took this video as an example
i knew their comment wasn't genuine and they just wanted to shit on Aespa performance because i remember this user from the old forum x)))
and i was right at the moment she said the vocal were pre recorded when there's proof that it was live
that just prove that too much people are trying to sound like vocal expert when they can't even make the difference between a real live performance or not '-'
Display Moreand that's when you prove that you can't even make the difference between lip sync and real live
I'm so embarass for you :-D:-D:-D:-D
i especially took this performance as a proof because i knew that you couldn't even make the difference and just wanted to shit on Aespa performance
too bad for you that SM drop the behind the scene of this performance, and the girls were singing live
Display Morei'm so emabrass for this fake people
that's why i took this video as an example
i knew their comment wasn't genuine and they just wanted to shit on Aespa performance because i remember this user from the old forum x)))
and i was right at the moment she said the vocal were pre recorded when there's proof that it was live
that just prove that too much people are trying to sound like vocal expert when they can't even make the difference between a real live performance or not '-'
I watched the whole video and wouldn't call this "proof" that it wasn't pre-recorded, I still don't hear any live singing lol.... also it's pretty transparent how you're trying to write off my genuine opinion as being a "hater" just because it shatters your perfectly constructed idea of this group. i've said multiple times, including in my OP, that i'm a fan of Aespa, i think they're talented, and i want them to sing live. but i guess in your mind anyone who questions their performance is just a "hater".
it doesn't make someone a hater to admit a group isn't singing live. like i said, it's SM's fault, not the girls. and I even admit with my bias BP that they lip sync sometimes.
it feels like you're escalating this argument to be more than it is. i really am a fan, but i guess you'll never believe me lol
i've said multiple times, including in my OP, that i'm a fan of Aespa, i think they're talented, and i want them to sing live. but i guess in your mind anyone who questions their performance is just a "hater".
it doesn't make someone a hater to admit a group isn't singing live. like i said, it's SM's fault, not the girls. and I even admit with my bias BP that they lip sync sometimes.
no you denying everytime people bring you proof of Aespa singing live
because you're so entrench to this idea of Aespa never sing live and only lip sync when it's obviously not true and by the same occassion discrediting their live performance and hard work
and acting like Aespa never sing live in one of their performance is what made you a hater
Display Moreand that's when you prove that you can't even make the difference between lip sync and real live
I'm so embarass for you :-D:-D:-D:-D
i especially took this performance as a proof because i knew that you couldn't even make the difference and just wanted to shit on Aespa performance
too bad for you that SM drop the behind the scene of this performance, and the girls were singing live
i love aespa but thats not live, this is not how a live performance sounds, if they did sung live, SM edited the performance way to much, can barely call it live
LITERAL GOOSEBUMPS WHEN SHE SANG MARIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA~
MARING-NING INSTEAD! 
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
