Katseye's cb is just so disappointing

Let’s agree to disagree

Katseye is absurdly amazing this comeback 💕

speak for yourself.

touch was formulaic and boring, could have been a song by illit or lsfm or anyone else. now THIS, this has some soul in it, and not everyone could make it work.

my opinion about katseye changed 180 degrees after gnarly

As katseye said “there’s a lot coming and you don’t have to like this song”

This was just the first song they promoted from their upcoming album and they confirmed the songs on the album are very different from gnarly.

Also gnarly was for the girls and the gays. Get that right.

I kinda like it. But it's definitely not gp friendly. It shouldn't have been the title track.

song is horrendous, but their stage presence is crazy good. i had to watch all their performances of this cb.

Quote from ISaidISaid

As katseye said “there’s a lot coming and you don’t have to like this song”

This was just the first song they promoted from their upcoming album and they confirmed the songs on the album are very different from gnarly.

Also gnarly was for the girls and the gays. Get that right.

Oh wow you’re following them!

Quote from visualkei4402

I kinda like it. But it's definitely not gp friendly. It shouldn't have been the title track.

It’s not the title track! Gnarly is a pre-release.

Quote from visualkei4402

I kinda like it. But it's definitely not gp friendly. It shouldn't have been the title track.

To tell you the truth, these days i don't even know what gp friendly song sounds. I feel like everything can do well, it depends on luck. And this isn't the title track.

Don't worry, disappointment is part of kpop marketing.

Because 1) you'll be curious to see how bad their choreo must be (surprise! It's funny!)

And then 2) you'll try to listen to it 10 times (because you like the choreoy) to understand it and start to appreciate it.

3) you'll put it on your playlist and try to convince people with good taste that it's awesome.

4) Then you'll become a fan and display Manon on your phone screen.

5) Then Hybe will make you pay because you'll start thinking about buying a ticket to see this abomination.

Did I forget something? 🤔

Quote from Zoenoe

It's just so bad and really the p star expressions are sending me over the edge. Because that's literally what they are, all those dumb over the top expressions literally come from p.

I can't be the only one wondering how and why you're so familiar with "p star expressions," whatever that even is. You're still weird for making this reference, though.

I honestly don't see the point in even expanding outside of Asia if the revenue it brings in is going to be negligible to the cost of running these subsidiaries.

What does “p star expressions” mean?

And their stage presence is good. Agree that song is horrendous and the choreo looks goofy, but you can’t deny that they can deliver and make a statement

Quote from Taemin-Identity

What does “p star expressions” mean?

And their stage presence is good. Agree that song is horrendous and the choreo looks goofy, but you can’t deny that they can deliver and make a statement

pretty sure its c*rn but the first letter is swapped out for the 16th letter in the english alphabet

Quote from Zoenoe

Like I hope the men are fed!

Just noticing this other weird comment.

Seriously, what is wrong with AKP being infested with a bunch of dirty minded weirdos. First "p star expressions" and now u trying to imply that this comeback is meant for a specific demographic. Are you coo..?

Maybe they're just having fun on stage??? Like...

Also this isn’t directed at men 100%. Most likely men won’t listen to this type of music, primarily because of horrendous lyrics.

This is 100% directed at gen Z audience, women and queer people.

Quote from bagelbaguette

pretty sure its c*rn but the first letter is swapped out for the 16th letter in the english alphabet

Hmmm very weird comment then.

Quote from Zoenoe

It's just so bad and really the p star expressions

?

Quote from Zoenoe

Like I hope the men are fed! Cos the girls are starving tonight

From orbit to orbit, can you stop promoting misogynistic beliefs? It's stupid. And plenty of girls - such as myself - LOVED this comeback and think it's iconic. We are not starving. Stop speaking for all women because you clearly do not know what you're talking about.

It's fine to not like the song or the choreo. But sometimes bitches want to be sexy and twerk and sway their hips. Doesn't make them "p stars" which, by the way, shouldn't even be an insult. Don't be demeaning to women, regardless of their occupation.

Orbits already have a terrible rep, stop contributing to it by being a misogynistic idiot. You know what? I revoke your orbit card.

Quote from CaraFIMIE

Just noticing this other weird comment.

Seriously, what is wrong with AKP being infested with a bunch of dirty minded weirdos. First "p star expressions" and now u trying to imply that this comeback is meant for a specific demographic. Are you coo..?

Maybe they're just having fun on stage??? Like...

I didn't understand what OP meant with Ps otherwise i would have commented on it. I watched a lot of their performances and not once i did i think they looked like porn stars. OP has outted themselves as a weirdo. Good to know

I don't even think the choreo is that sexual

They just twerk very fast while spinning

I think even Elvis was more than that, we are in 2025

Quote from Taemin-Identity

This is 100% directed at gen Z audience, women and queer people.

I'm gay, and I think it's shite!

Quote from BIGnorBANG

I'm gay, and I think it's shite!

I’m gen Z and I also think it is sh*t😂

But it is 100% not directed at men.

Quote from bagelbaguette

pretty sure its c*rn but the first letter is swapped out for the 16th letter in the english alphabet

Wouldn't it be better to just say ahegao faces?

Kpop stans like this type of music let's not lie. Lots of noise groups have dedicated stans. Problem is that Katseye with their debut music were appealing to easy listening music stans and with this comeback they have decided they don't want those fans. That's it.

It just got worse...

Quote from Zoenoe

Because im a grown adult whose seen c*rn in my lifetime. Not everyones a 15 year old who thinks everythings "iconic" 💀 You guys are so innocent honestly

What's with censoring corn? You aren't even censoring porn but corn and you call yourself adult. I know that it might be hard for you to get but the vast majority of people here are 20+, we also have users who are 30+ and 40+. There are very few users bellow 18. We aren't naive as you'd like to think. We just don't have a dirty mind like yourself.

Quote from Zoenoe

Because im a grown adult whose seen c*rn in my lifetime. Not everyones a 15 year old who thinks everythings "iconic" 💀 You guys are so innocent honestly

Not innocent but instead decent human beings who don't make baseless references to porn.

Quote from CaraFIMIE

Not innocent but instead decent human beings who don't make baseless references to porn.

OP is obsessed with creepy men. Imagine consuming content thinking "hmm, creepy (old) men would like this". They can just say the choreo and their facial expressions are too much for me instead of comparing them to porn stars. I don't like a lot of performances from popular artists because i find them too sexual but not once did i say they should do porn instead of singing. And it might be surprising to some but women like sexy too, not just men.

All in all, such a weird take.

If I were female and/or gay, I would be highly offended by the suggestions in this thread that this god awful noise is aimed squarely at consumers like myself. Surely the musical taste of half the planet cannot be THAT bad.

Also, why can't you dildos just type the word "porn" like actual grown adults?

Quote from doesitneedsaying

OP is obsessed with creepy men. Imagine consuming content thinking "hmm, creepy (old) men would like this". They can just say the choreo and their facial expressions are too much for me instead of comparing them to porn stars. I don't like a lot of performanse from popular artists because i find them too sexual but not once did i say they should do porn instead of singing. And it might be surprising to some but women like sexy too, not just men.

All in all, such a weird take.

I'm honestly just ashamed to be a man sometimes.

The shit some of them say is just

Quote from msmelon

It’s not the title track! Gnarly is a pre-release.

Oh cool !! I didn't know...

Quote from CaraFIMIE

I'm honestly just ashamed to be a man sometimes.

The shit some of them say is just

Lucky for you it's not just men :D weirdos come in all genders.

Imagine watching something thinking weirdos would really like this??? Wtf. I'm still not over reading that

So I finally caved in and gave a listen. Not my cup of tea, but not as bad as O.O.

The biggest question I was left with is how is a Tesla ever considered gnarly? To me, a gnarly car would be like a ford mustang, or a monster truck or a hot rod or something. Calling a Tesla gnarly is like calling an electric Hyundai gnarly lol

Quote from Bottles

So I finally caved in and gave a listen. Not my cup of tea, but not as bad as O.O.

The biggest question I was left with is how is a Tesla ever considered gnarly? To me, a gnarly car would be like a ford mustang, or a monster truck or a hot rod or something. Calling a Tesla gnarly is like calling an electric Hyundai gnarly lol

Also, gnarly can mean two things, though I know it was predominantly used as good, rather than bad... Are they trying to say the song is good? I hate to tell the producers, but... it's anything but good...

Quote from Bottles

but not as bad as O.O.

O.O is a masterpiece

Quote from Bottles

how is a Tesla ever considered gnarly?

ugly car from an ugly brand owner

I don’t think disappointing is the right word

Quote from CaraFIMIE

ugly car from an ugly brand owner

well yeah, agreed. But I thought they were listing things they found cool - like Boba tea and Fried Chicken