BLACKPINK vs TWICE...
-
-
-
-
-
twice
-
Twice....... by a bit.
-
Well this is laughable. And it's all the usual suspects.
-
I like both groups so I'll let RNGesus decide
heads for BP
tails for Twice
TAILS!!! Twice TWICE TWICE
-
Colour Color obviously
-
-
Twice has better singers, better dancers and better performers. The only thing BP has edge over Twice is their Rap, but I don’t see them utilising it much.
-
The winner of this poll will get a chance to compete against the third option.
Cool your rainbow and vote.
So that means Twice will win twice.
-
-
Definitely Blackpink, they have much more stable live vocals and twice don’t really have any dance skills to write home about.
Because Blackpink are definitely known for their stable vocals and powerful, well-synchronized dance routines.
In what universe?
Do some of you consume Kpop with a blindfold and ear plugs?
-
-
-
Blinks...
-
TWICE by a mile. BP can't sing or dance.
-
-
-
-
Bottles is your alt, isn't it?
-
In life successful people use their opportunities with talent or effort they have to create differences. So far each bp members achieving greater things because they're talented as idol singers/rapper/dancer plus having star factor, and great personalities to create somewhat genuine connections with big names. 3 out of 4 choose to become ceo and pocketing all the income for their own team, money savvy is also a talent needed in this world.
-
-
VS in what?
-
So that means Twice will win twice.
Definitely Blackpink, they have much more stable live vocals and twice don’t really have any dance skills to write home about.
Meanwhile TWICE, with 9 people, are better able to match each other's energy even though not all of them are wellrounded.
Which group?
-
Definitely Blackpink, they have much more stable live vocals and twice don’t really have any dance skills to write home about.
Lives in Bizzaro world apparently.
-
Since neither group is a Mamamoo or Red Velvet, I think it really depends on what people mean by 'talent.' Because to me, neither TWICE nor BLACKPINK is amazing at any one specific thing. For example, Jennie isn’t on Solar or Hwasa’s level vocally, and neither is Nayeon. But Jennie is definitely a much stronger performer on stage and a better dancer. On the other hand, Nayeon might not be an incredible vocalist, but her voice really stands out in TWICE’s songs, and she has the kind of charisma that can hold attention even in a large group.
Funny enough, even though I personally consider Mamamoo and Red Velvet more 'talented' as groups overall, I don’t think either of them has a member like Jennie or Nayeon in terms of that specific type of impact or versatility.
If we talk about dance Momo clearly stands out and can definitely be considered a great dancer. Same goes for Lisa. But both of them are vocally below average. I’m not saying they’re bad, just that they’re not at the same level as their dance skills. So, while I don’t instinctively call Momo or Lisa 'talented' in the general sense, I do think they’re very talented when it comes to dancing.
What I’m trying to say is: for me, to consider a group truly talented, they need to have fewer noticeably weak members and more individuals who are closer to being all-rounders. Based on that logic, BLACKPINK comes across as more talented than TWICE to me.
-
..than Nayeon??? Um
Jennie's great but imagine trying to claim Jennie is a better dancer than Nayeon when all the dances Jennie is credited for is elementary level choreo. Have you even seen TWICE's choreos? The amount of engagement and dynamics it has is something only Lisa in BLACKPINK is capable of.
What I’m trying to say is: for me, to consider a group truly talented, they need to have fewer noticeably weak members and more individuals who are closer to being all-rounders. Based on that logic, BLACKPINK comes across as more talented than TWICE to me.
This logic doesn't even make sense. Few members of TWICE can actually dance but they are still WAY better and match each other's energy better than the 3/4 of BP.
TWICE Main Vocalist ≈ BP Main Vocalist
TWICE Lead Vocalists >>> BP Lead Vocalists
TWICE Sub Vocalists >>>>> BP Sub Vocalist
BP Rapper >>>>>> TWICE Rappers
TWICE Main Dancers > BP Main Dancer
TWICE Lead Dancers >>> BP Lead Dancers
You were saying?
-
TWICE Main Dancers > BP Main Dancer
And before anyone comes for me, I'm only saying this because Lisa and Momo, I believe, are on the same level when it comes to dancing. But if you factor in Mina, who is also a Main Dancer, her 11 years of ballet easily puts Lisa (or any member of BP as a matter of fact) to shame.
-
Display More
Jennie's great but imagine trying to claim Jennie is a better dancer than Nayeon when all the dances Jennie is credited for is elementary level choreo. Have you even seen TWICE's choreos? The amount of engagement and dynamics it has is something only Lisa in BLACKPINK is capable of.
This logic doesn't even make sense. Few members of TWICE can actually dance but they are still WAY better and match each other's energy better than the 3/4 of BP.
TWICE Main Vocalist ≈ BP Main Vocalist
TWICE Lead Vocalists >>> BP Lead Vocalists
TWICE Sub Vocalists >>>>> BP Sub Vocalist
BP Rapper >>>>>> TWICE Rappers
TWICE Main Dancers > BP Main Dancer
TWICE Lead Dancers >>> BP Lead Dancers
You were saying?
well, ı didn't claim jennie is better dancer than nayeon ı said "For example, Jennie isn’t on Solar or Hwasa’s level vocally, and neither is Nayeon. " means nayeon and jennie are not solar or hwasa in terms of "singing"
and nope I don’t feel like explaining myself at length but my logic just doesn’t work the same way as yours.
-
-
-
I don't get the purpose of making a poll and asking people their opinions if you only want one answer?
Mine is pretty similar to echo-sages. Twice has a better main vocal and better dancers but they also have a big skills gap that brings their average down. And Blackpink has better stage presence so it's them for me.
-
ok, whatever you call
-
well, ı didn't claim jennie is better dancer than nayeon ı said "For example, Jennie isn’t on Solar or Hwasa’s level vocally, and neither is Nayeon. " means nayeon and jennie are not solar or hwasa in terms of "singing"
and nope I don’t feel like explaining myself at length but my logic just doesn’t work the same way as yours.
And I can simplify it for you:
2/4 members of BLACKPINK can sing,
1/4 members of BLACKPINK can rap,
1/4 members of BLACKPINK can dance and neither can match each other's energy appropriately.
Now for TWICE:
3/9 members of TWICE can sing,
2/9 members of TWICE can rap,
4/9 members of TWICE can dance and all of them match each other's energy appropriately.
You can take away a point on rapping and singing, each for TWICE and give one of the those point to BP for rapping, and TWICE wins, either way.
If I were to use your logic, aka, more well rounded members = more talented group:
BLACPINK has one member that is wellrounded and that is Jennie.
TWICE has 2 members that are wellrounded and those are Jihyo and Nayeon.
TWICE still wins.
-
-
-
Display More
And I can simplify it for you:
2/4 members of BLACKPINK can sing,
1/4 members of BLACKPINK can rap,
1/4 members of BLACKPINK can dance and neither can match each other's energy appropriately.
Now for TWICE:
3/9 members of TWICE can sing,
2/9 members of TWICE can rap,
4/9 members of TWICE can dance and all of them match each other's energy appropriately.
You can take away a point on rapping and singing, each for TWICE and give one of the those point to BP for rapping, and TWICE wins, either way.
If I were to use your logic, aka, more well rounded members = more talented group:
BLACPINK has one member that is wellrounded and that is Jennie.
TWICE has 2 members that are wellrounded and those are Jihyo and Nayeon.
TWICE still wins.
nope,
2/4 members of BLACKPINK can sing,
2 4 members of BLACKPINK can rap,
3/4 members of BLACKPINK can dance and (neither can match each other's energy appropriately.) = dont care, the fact that they’re not as synchronized as TWICE when dancing doesn’t really look off or awkward. and I think Jennie is above average or at the very least average when it comes to dancing. So yeah, she can dance.
-
Performer: only when she feels like it and way too often, she does not.
Dancer: too many lazy looking dancing, so no.
-
No you are not being objective. We both know it so drop the act.
Your only reason for choosing BLACKPINK is because there is a bigger skills gap in TWICE which, yes, is true but thats probably because TWICE has more members. There's a bigger opportunity for skills coordination in a group of 4 vs a group of 9. You're very well aware of this which is precisely why you use this logic to back up your "solid and consistent" standpoint.
And before you claim that I'm biased..its true. I am biased towards BLACKPINK, believe it or not.
nope,
2/4 members of BLACKPINK can sing,
2 4 members of BLACKPINK can rap,
3/4 members of BLACKPINK can dance and (neither can match each other's energy appropriately.) = dont care, the fact that they’re not as synchronized as TWICE when dancing doesn’t really look off or awkward. and I think Jennie is above average or at the very least average when it comes to dancing. So yeah, she can dance.
Ah yes. Now we're at the point of you minimizing the important of one talent just because our faves don't measure up, in that area.
I won't even argue with any of you, any further because I'm not sure why I would expect you guys to actually be objective. Anyways, if you're going to claim that 3/4 members of BP can dance (very false) then bring some receipts.
-
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
