Do you think Lisa can sing?

Define sing

I mean yes, everyone who isn't mute "can" sing.

It just depends on whether or not they are good at it and Lisa isn't very good at it, I fear.

Quote from Yama-Chan

You both know what I mean

Let's set aside semantics

Well then I don't know.

She's better than some but lesser than most.

I hate to be the David of this thread but Moonbyul who holds no vocal position in her group can outsing Lisa, who is the sub-vocalist of BP.

I won't even compare her to any of her 3rd gen peers because the weakest vocal member of any of them can easily outsing her.

4/5 members of LSF can outsing her, and the entire group is basically considered the weakest 4th gen gg in vocals. The entirety of BAEMON, her juniors within the same company, can outsing her. I'm pretty sure most members of ILLIT (again, considered the weakest 5th gen gg in vocals), can outsing her.

Even, UNIS' Seowon, who was literally 6 or 7 years old when BLACKPINK debuted, can outsing Lisa.

So... go figure.

And what do YOU think? Don't assume you can go under the radar by making us take the fall.

Yes she can sing! Is she a Beyoncé or Whitney? No! Is she a Taylor or Selena? Probably

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

3 big exaggerations here

The first one, yes because I don't really know much 3rd gen ggs other than the mainstream ones. The last two is true, tho. Make a poll asking who the weakest gg of 4th and 5th gen, vocally is and you'll see who wins.

Quote from foreveraespaaa

Is she a Taylor or Selena? Probably

Yes, she can. She isn't the best, but as I said she never destroyed her or her group career over her singing "ability" unlike some groups we know who or unlike some soloists who had to stop a whole era over it.

Her strength is rapping and dancing, but I enjoy her songs and in there she sings more.

giphy (20).gif

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

Oh no, it's definitely those 2 groups at the very bottom, but Lisa is NOT getting outsung by Eunchae and most of whoever is illit

She's not that bad

That's fair. I need a SouMu to let Eunchae showcase her vocals first before I make that judgement because I really do think she has improved but for ILLIT, I'm pretty sure the only member that's lacking in the slightest bit is Iroha.

Quote from monalisalove

unlike some soloists who had to stop a whole era over it

whoooo

Quote from CaraFIMIE

whoooo

I want peace while being shade kkkkk but it's relatively recent

Quote from monalisalove

I want peace while being shade kkkkk but it's relatively recent

give me a hint, juseyo

Quote from CaraFIMIE

give me a hint, juseyo

It all started bc of an encore

Quote from monalisalove

It all started bc of an encore

am I missing an entire chapter lol

Quote from CaraFIMIE

am I missing an entire chapter lol

you are...

Quote from monalisalove

you are...

Quote from Yama-Chan

You both know what I mean

Let's set aside semantics

She can move her vocal cords.

Can she make a pleasant sound with them? No, no she cannot.

She can, she sang Dream. But she cannot sing while dancing

She has one of the most distinctive and pleasant vocal tones in all of Kpop. I just dont understand why she has to lipsync/bactrack it all the time. I'm not as upset about the autotuning, that is literally industry standard at this point everyone does it, i've given up trashing artists for it.

She's a serviceable idol singer.

Of course not. She's terrible.

Absolutely not

Quote from Yama-Chan

You both know what I mean

Let's set aside semantics

but this is kpop and AKP semantics matter a lot lol

if the question was

"does one think lisa can sing well" or "is lisa a below average singer" then the answer might be different but yes Lisa can sing

Quote from CaraFIMIE

That's fair. I need a SouMu to let Eunchae showcase her vocals first before I make that judgement because I really do think she has improved but for ILLIT, I'm pretty sure the only member that's lacking in the slightest bit is Iroha.

Forgetting Moka?

What's the standard?

Quote from CaraFIMIE

I hate to be the David of this thread but Moonbyul who holds no vocal position in her group can outsing Lisa, who is the sub-vocalist of BP.

Ended BP

ofc, i can also sing

lalala

Quote from what-if-i

Forgetting Moka?

Moka was never that bad. Most people just let that one encore dictate how they perceive her vocal ability when in reality, it was just a minor slipup from being nervous.

Quote from icyruios

Ended BP

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

The way I actually love her voice, here

Quote from CaraFIMIE

Moka was never that bad. Most people just let that one encore dictate how they perceive her vocal ability when in reality, it was just a minor slipup from being nervous.

The way I actually love her voice, here

Ok, I will respect your standards on vocals ig

Quote from what-if-i

Ok, I will respect your standards on vocals ig

That isn't really my standard lmao

Obviously, Moka still has a lot of room for improvement but I'm very sure Lisa is not much better off.

Leaving aside her fandom, the vast majority think she can't sing. I'm with this majority.

No she can't.

Quote from Varenka

There are billions of people alive that can't sing as well as she can.

Ah yes. This is the bar in kpop these days. Bare minimum for the lowest common denominator.

I would not consider new jeans and Lisa to be on vastly different levels of singing if that answers your question.