Let's be real, this line up G-Idle would still break the charts.

People don't ask if a group would be better off without their "favorite member." Even if you consider her a weak link, what would her absence improve? They wouldn't suddenly be a dynamite vocal group without her.

They dont need Shuhua at all musically. But, she is hilarious with her variety show appearances and obviously has a lot of stans.

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

My Favorite member is Shuhua, but I will admit that she is the weakest link.

After Soojin left, they are hopeless, with or without Shushu

dat dizrespect tho

It doesn't look with the current direction there will be huge growth, so I expect at minimum a semi-hiatus like BP next year.

When they go into solo activities, she going to be huge as an actress. Both Yuqi and her will just themselves will be bigger than the group.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

They dont need Shuhua at all musically. But, she is hilarious with her variety show appearances and obviously has a lot of stans.

This. She has a fun personality too.

Also, I remember how she stood up to bullies on Vlive and didn't give a f, especially for a Kpop idol

Flop take

nope

I don't think she has any effect on song charting but certainly on sales charting.

Quote from hokiedood

I don't think she has any effect on song charting but certainly on sales charting.

On second thought, I think IDLE's song and sales charting would sustain or maybe even grow without her. Soojin was an even more integral member as a vocalist, performer, and stan attractor. The group skyrocketed after she left.

but isn't shuhua good at variety? that helps a lot also the dynamic of the group

Quote from Slayurfaves

but isn't shuhua good at variety? that helps a lot also the dynamic of the group

Yeah, i used to consider her as a filler member or at most, a stan attractor that could sell a few more albums. But she showed some real personality on her variety show, had me chuckling multiple times ngl.

I like Gidle but even I have to admit she is the weakest member in terms of musical talents but apparently she's a stan attractor so different strokes for different folks