VCHA "Girls of the Year" Bop vs flop

boring

Reading comments i expected worst but it's fine, inoffensive song.

Voting blop because chorus is awful

I still don't know who is the target audience for this group. Because american gp most certainly isn't

The 5 second rap was 1/10. The song was 6/10. The mv 5/10. They lack x-factor, a lot.

They actually look like proper kpop group? Much better than whatever happened with their pre debut era.

Quote from tetetete

Why are the lyrics so weird like a first time songwriter or chatgpt

I just looked up the lyrics, and they did use English native writers. Unfortunately though, they used writers whose most well known credits are from KPOP, which I think was the 1st mistake. They should be using writers who are writing for the biggest pop stars in the Western scene.

The producers and lyricists who are tapped into the music scene, who know what the trend is now, and who know how to appeal to the teenage demographic of today. Instead, we got what we got. And, idk why. JYPE can literally afford the best writers and producers in the world, but instead, we got a very lackluster debut that is very meh. I neither love nor hate this.

They are still in their Disney channel bag, which is fine. But, at least get them a show on Nickelodeon or something if this is the route you want to go. Some preteens would eat this up! And they'd actually build somewhat of an appropriate fanbase that way.

Quote from KYL

this is just pop so it's a no for me. best of luck opening for twice. i think they're gonna need it

You're on a forum dedicated to pop music, in case you needed reminding.

(And before anyone exclaims "Kpop is different!" -- No, it's not.)

Quote from Popper-of-Ks

You're on a forum dedicated to pop music, in case you needed reminding.

(And before anyone exclaims "Kpop is different!" -- No, it's not.)

it was posted in the kpop section tho

it wasn't bad by any means but again I wonder who this groups audience is. Im assuming young girls in America but I dont think they will appeal to much to those types. I wish the girls luck and do think they have improved a lot in their performance. I looked forward to them opening for Twice.

it's actually not a bad as I thought. I kinda like the chorus after 3rd listen.

Only thing is it felt off... like it's an English song but also did not feel like an English song.

Like I don't need subtitles but I also kinda needed subtitles.

Quote from doesitneedsaying

Reading comments i expected worst but it's fine, inoffensive song.

Voting blop because chorus is awful

I still don't know who is the target audience for this group. Because american gp most certainly isn't

What does "american gp" mean ?

Quote from nobody4444

What does "american gp" mean ?

American general public

nevermind I like it, it's good.

It's just a nice girl group song, that's it. it's not really spectacular for a debut, but there's definitely far worse that has been released.

LOVED the instrumentals and beat. Real music, catchy vocals, it's a bop for sure.

Blop. It’s not bad, just unexceptional for a debut and I don’t like the lyrics in the chorus. I wish them well and hope they can find an audience.

Lmao what was that. Flop

It's giving wannabe Disney vibes