We cannot consider twice a top tier girl group any more

They have the digital performance of a 4th Gen boy group and the only thing they have going for them is physicals. If ATEEZ is able to sell 1m albums and isn’t considered a top boy group then the same thing should apply for twice. We need to stop taking into account their 2016-2018 charting because that was 4 years ago. The gp has clearly moved on and that is okay.

Current girl group tier ranking:

S Tier: BLACKPINK

A tier: SNSD, IVE, NewJeans, AESPA, Red Velvet

B Tier: TWICE, G-Idle, Itzy

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

SNSD in A tier?

They aren’t S Tier as of right now. They definitely were during their prime but we’re talking as of now

Quote from TheLadybug

yeah we can

On what basis? Their short lived fame that only lasted 2 years? We can consider twice a fad at this point

Quote from z1

They still have better international numbers than most of the ggs there so no.

Their so called international numbers were surpassed by IVE, NewJeans, and AESPA with ease

Quote from TheLadybug

idk man overall recognition

i don't live in korea, but where i am the most well known gg aside from bp is twice for sure

definitely do not have stats to fight you with but just speaking from general experience

sure the new ggs have a lot of buzz and will eventually take over but i think for now twice is still more well known overall ??

The numbers speak for themselves

Quote from obok

lets look at the sales

Their album only sold 200k copies the first day on Hanteo… even nugu boy groups can outdo that

Quote from obok

what about the pre-orders? they sold 1m

Pre orders don’t translate to actual sales.