Whose solo did better in Korea, Nayeon's or Joy's?

Yes, I like Nayeon.

Wasn't joy's a remake album?

overall joy did better on charts

Nayeon easily.

Joy song wasn't a hit. I guess it's overall performance was a bit lower than alcohol free. Cmiiaw

I feel like Pop had the most impact of all the songs

Pop both the title and the bsides charted in sk and internationally if I'm not wrong.

I like Nayeon too just like that horizon bloke

Gotta be a joke

nayeon pop did better i think. Nayeons pop choreo also became viral which help the song to bceome popular. Joys song didnt have any point choreo like pop

As if it was hard

nayeon

Quote from SooYoung

I think title track wise Nayeon did better the song peaked and have a great longevity in the top 10

but album wise digitally Joy did much better, she had 3-4 songs charting on melon top 100

do you have the gaon numbers for both their respective albums?

Quote from SooYoung

If i'm not wrong joy album did 112M in one month

And all the track of the album enter gaon digital chart

But i can't find the numbers for nayeon album

cheers anyway

atropos

you're the numbers person my friend

do you have numbers for both Joy's and Nayeon's album?

Quote from selfmate

cheers anyway

atropos

you're the numbers person my friend

do you have numbers for both Joy's and Nayeon's album?

Nayeon didn't have any bsides chart. But pop is doing very well and continue to gain points

Quote from atropos

Nayeon didn't have any bsides chart. But pop is doing very well and continue to gain points

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

cheers mate

so it would seem that Pop did way better than hello but joy's album as a whole did better than Nayeon's album...

interesting

Quote from selfmate

cheers mate

so it would seem that Pop did way better than hello but joy's album as a whole did better than Nayeon's album...

interesting

U can say that joy's bsides did end up doing better. But if we take album cumulative after sometime most probably nayeon will take that too because of pop.

Quote from atropos

U can say that joy's bsides did end up doing better. But if we take album cumulative after sometime most probably nayeon will take that too because of pop.

I guess time will tell

which then raises an interesting question...

assuming Pop does as well as Joy's entire album but none of Im Nayeon other songs chart...

would one say then they performed equally as well or one did better than the other?

Quote from selfmate

cheers mate

so it would seem that Pop did way better than hello but joy's album as a whole did better than Nayeon's album...

interesting

Joy's voice is loved in korea, that's why all album songs have been listened to. Also Jyp's bsides in general don't appeal to me and Pop, was like Twice's old songs so it's not surprising that it was more successful. Twice more popular groupthan RV. But despite that, Joy's solo definitely did a good job. So Nayeon is more successful, but we can't say that Joy is unsuccessful if her overall album is listened to that much. Both successful their own standard.