Ultimate Christmas Battle : Twice vs Loona

vs

which of these would you consider superior?

imo both have the warmest MVs

The Carol has the sweetest melody in existence

but Merry and Happy's lyrics are one of the most beautiful in all of kpop

Quote from Whi

Haseul’s vocals >>

I also prefer loona’s song and mv cinematography so like it wins by a landslide lol

i mean, haseul's vocals are S tier but Merry and Happy isnt really vocal dependent at all so it doesnt make a difference here imo

that said, if you're a fan of vocals, its an easy win for The Carol

btw I think that was the song where Heejin really showed a massive leap in vocals too

Quote from Whi

i mean as long as a piece of music features vocals and not just the instrumentals they’ll always factor in influencing my liking of it no matter how brief or prominent the vocal performance is. I’m one of those people that can be absolutely turned off from a song if the singing is bad, no matter how good the music itself might be lol

i understand

js its kind of redundant in this comparison cause neither song was really affected negatively by the vocals

and trust me I dont watch 99% kpop live stages because of bad vocals

Quote from Whi

yeah ik. I wasn’t commenting on either group’s vocals in my previous post, just a general assessment of my preference. But since this thread is literally called a “battle” and asks “which one is superior” it’s basically impossible to avoid comparisons between the 2 songs, and since haseul’s vocals are obviously superior, which is a fact, idt my answer was really that controversial lol

never said its controversial

i believe in haseul vocal supremacy too
just wanted to have a discussion

that said, in The Carol Heejin's vocals surprised me the most. She was naturally talented since debut but it was around this era she really started showing massive improvements

now of course, my expectations from her are very high