[Enter Talk] This is apparently what the ranking based on idols earning on YouTube

Nakayuki · Dec 12th 2021

Source:

[enter-talk] THIS IS APPARENTLY WHAT THE RANKING BASED ON IDOLS' EARNINGS ON YOUTUBE

pann-choa.blogspot.com

Tbh, the comments under the pannchoa article is funnier tho. People fighting about their fave's earning like their own?

Nakayuki · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from dummi

TXT are so selfish for not sharing that money they hate their fans fakes & fads

TXT spent it for their expensive Celine outfits in MAMA red carpet. And to feed Odi.

sassily · Dec 12th 2021

as ever the real story is the huge difference between 1 & 2 and the rest cause it's ginormous.

Pearl-Iris · Dec 12th 2021

Yeah, surprised that SKZ and ITZY didn't make it in the list, happy for TXT

kidsgonestray · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from Pearl-Iris

Yeah, surprised that SKZ and ITZY didn't make it in the list, happy for TXT

It’s because their music videos aren’t posted on their proper YouTube channel. It’s also why TWICE isn’t on there.

I think HYBE at least managed to link their artists YT to their M/V’s, hence why they’re there!

idontsleep · Dec 12th 2021

Forbes and ignoring JYPE groups, find a better duo

Nakayuki · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from dummi

Odi looks more and more like a golf ball these days. A... spiky golf ball. Anyway so can we say that TXT are successful YouTubers now? Makeup tutorial pls

The reality, majority of videos are random things like this

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Nakayuki · Dec 12th 2021

Found this on comment

Full list for the curious:

1. BANGTAN TV

(57.1 million subscribers / 12.5 billion views total / 1512 uploaded videos / 16.5 million USD yearly earnings)

2. BLACKPINK

(64.5 million subscribers / 19.2 billion views total / 359 uploaded videos / 11.6 million USD yearly earnings)

3. NCT DREAM

(3.95 million subscribers / 395 million views total / 213 uploaded videos/ 1.9 million USD yearly earnings)

4. Seventeen

(6.85 million subscribers / 2.2 billion views total / 842 uploaded videos/ 1.7 million USD yearly earnings)

5. BamBam Space

(1.07 million subscribers / 78 million views total / 46 uploaded videos/ 1.5 million USD yearly earnings)

6. MAMAMOO

(6.07 million subscribers / 1.6 billion views total / 593uploaded videos/ 1.5 million USD yearly earnings)

7. EXO

(8.31 million subscribers / 472 million views total / 194 uploaded videos/ 1.5 million USD yearly earnings)

8. Lee Ji Geum (IU Official)

(6.7 million subscribers / 953 million views total / 124 uploaded videos/ 1.4 million USD yearly earnings)

9. Aespa

(2.35 million subscribers / 283 million views total / 59 uploaded videos/ 1.2 million USD yearly earnings)

10. TXT

(7.54 million subscribers / 468 million views total / 705 uploaded videos/ 989,395 USD yearly earnings)

13. Red Velvet

(4.41 million subscribers / 620 million views total / 131 uploaded videos/ 675,209 USD yearly earnings)

14. LOONA

(1.67 million subscribers / 589.9 million views total / 1,026 uploaded videos/ 674,968 USD yearly earnings)

16. CHANNEL NCT DAILY

(4.21 million subscribers / 730 million views total / 467 uploaded videos/ 432,955 USD yearly earnings)

19. AKMU

(2.54 million subscribers / 635 million views total / 119 uploaded videos/ 322,949 USD yearly earnings)

20. NCT

(4.22 million subscribers / 282 million views total / 204 uploaded videos/ 314,092 USD yearly earnings)

PinKookiE · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from kidsgonestray

It’s because their music videos aren’t posted on their proper YouTube channel. It’s also why TWICE isn’t on there.

I think HYBE at least managed to link their artists YT to their M/V’s, hence why they’re there!

JYP and SM do the same, they upload the mvs on the company channel and random videos and teasers on the groups' channels, i don't understand why Twice is not here but EXO and NCT are, even aespa.

**bartkun** · Dec 12th 2021

no but TWICE with all their releases should be here for sure!

also I'm curious how much Solar earns, she now has 3.3M subs on her channel

kidsgonestray · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from PinKookiE

JYP and SM do the same, they upload the mvs on the company channel and random videos and teasers on the groups' channels, i don't understand why Twice is not here but EXO and NCT are, even aespa.

Must be something on the internal side, seriously. Like, the fact that TWICE isn’t there is shocking.

ninichan · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from idontsleep

Forbes and ignoring JYPE groups, find a better duo

i saw online (twitter) that perhaps its because the jype youtube isnt marked as from south korea

for instance here is blackpink, and here is jype. blackpink has location: south korea, but jype doesnt

pasted-from-clipboard.png

ninichan · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from bartkun

no but TWICE with all their releases should be here for sure!

also I'm curious how much Solar earns, she now has 3.3M subs on her channel

Quote from kidsgonestray

Must be something on the internal side, seriously. Like, the fact that TWICE isn’t there is shocking.

Quote from PinKookiE

JYP and SM do the same, they upload the mvs on the company channel and random videos and teasers on the groups' channels, i don't understand why Twice is not here but EXO and NCT are, even aespa.

supposedly it's because the jype channel has not marked its location as south korea. all the channels on this list have their locations marked as south korea

idontsleep · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from ninichan

i saw online (twitter) that perhaps its because the jype youtube isnt marked as from south korea

for instance here is blackpink, and here is jype. blackpink has location: south korea, but jype doesnt

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

That's so stupid tho.

ninichan · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from idontsleep

That's so stupid tho.

i think they just have a bot compiling chanels from south korea and ranking them

i doubt theyre going searching manually for korean channels

but yeah, its dumb

idontsleep · Dec 12th 2021

Quote from ninichan

i think they just have a bot compiling chanels from south korea and ranking them

i doubt theyre going searching manually for korean channels

but yeah, its dumb

Same thing was with forbes earning rankings in 2019 or 2020 when they put Twice at like 23 spot iirc after some nugu groups.

kmac1 · Dec 12th 2021

These lists are usually put together with stats from socialblade, so Twice should be 3rd.

tetetete · Dec 12th 2021

this forbes korea is not at all reliable imo

Tic_tac_toe · Dec 12th 2021

Is this their merch bot channel with the teasers oh I’m surprised they’re making that much of it

nahadoth · Dec 12th 2021

This list doesn't make much sense to me. How can bambam be that high while twice don't make the list at all?

[Enter Talk] This is apparently what the ranking based on idols earning on YouTube

Participate now!

Share

Similar Threads

[Entertalk Pann] Former Korean soldier lays out rational and empirical arguments as to why he supports BTS' exemption from the army

My Opinion On How You Like That Cultural Appropriation Controversy

Companies should stop recruiting idols based on visual

[PannChoa] Kingdom 2nd round ranking + continuous disregardance of emotional/vocal based performances

[enter-talk] YG BP'S HOOBAE GROUP SPOILER REVEALED

storytime: me sharing wayyyy too personal things on the internet again haha

Users Viewing This Thread