Line distributions should reflect talent and how well members suit the line.
I don't get why people want equal distributions
Another controversial opinion(even more controversial)
-
-
I do agree line distributions are mostly not unfair. They are uneven, but most of the time they are fair. I will quote some examples.
Gfriend initially was heavy on the top4 and umji and sowon gets very little lines as their vocals are unstable. As they progress, the line distribution become more even as umji proved to be a good vocalist and sowon has become more stable.
Another example is GIDLE. To me, their line distribution fair most of the time. People have been making noise for shuhua little lines but the fact is she is the most unstable singer in the group and arguably not the strongesr performer in the group. Though i really think some easier lines could be given to her...
-
honestly some Reveluvs pissed me off during psycho era crying that Wendy and Seulgi and Joy get to much lines like uhm mam Irene and Yeri are literally sub vocals (albeit good sub vocals) but they can not execute WenSeulJoy lines Joy and Seulgi barley could handle Wendys lines I doubt Irene and Yeri wpuld do much better.
-
I don't get it when people get mad the main vocalist or main rapper gets more lines. Like of course they do. That's why they're in that main position. Like I've never seen anyone complain when one of the main dancers is at the center for the dance break* so why do people get mad when the main vocal has the most lines?
I also think sometimes people only look at title tracks. Sometimes their voice just doesn't work on a track but you will hear them all over the b sides. For example Lee Know on God's Menu only had a small amount of lines, but is very well represented through the rest of the album.
*Okay I totally have seen that but it's often when the main dancer is also a main vocal/rapper/face of the group.
Agree
-
-
A fair line distribution doesn’t mean an equal line distribution. Each member deserves to receive lines according to their skills. Sometimes it’s a bit baffling though when the main vocalist sings like 75 % of a song even easy lines that could be sung by anyone else in the group.
It’s harder to get a fair line distribution for larger groups like Loona.
-
A fair line distribution doesn’t mean an equal line distribution. Each member deserves to receive lines according to their skills. Sometimes it’s a bit baffling though when the main vocalist sings like 75 % of a song even easy lines that could be sung by anyone else in the group.
It’s harder to get a fair line distribution for larger groups like Loona.
But i think it's rare to have a main vocalist sing that much (75%ish) on their own. In fact I can't think of any examples where this happened.
But i agree with what you said about fair distribution being all about the skill level.
-
But i think it's rare to have a main vocalist sing that much (75%ish) on their own. In fact I can't think of any examples where this happened.
But i agree with what you said about fair distribution being all about the skill level.
Hyolyn says hello
-
-
But i think it's rare to have a main vocalist sing that much (75%ish) on their own. In fact I can't think of any examples where this happened.
But i agree with what you said about fair distribution being all about the skill level.
75 % is an exaggeration but 50-60 % I have seen it a lot. Gugudan for example and they were one of the best vocal groups.
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
