Oh, wow. I love Red Velvet and that song, but SNSD would have taken that song to a different level.
I know SNSD had a few fun title tracks etc. but I feel it was offered to them probably after Mr. Mr. and I don't think it would have fitted them anymore because SNSD pushed to the more mature, sophisticated and sometimes a bit edgy concepts (expect Party), while Red Flavour is more youthful and childish (I do like the sung though)
I know SNSD had a few fun title tracks etc. but I feel it was offered to them probably after Mr. Mr. and I don't think it would have fitted them anymore because SNSD pushed to the more mature, sophisticated and sometimes a bit edgy concepts (expect Party), while Red Flavour is more youthful and childish (I do like the sung though)
SNSD doing mature, sophisticated & edgy concepts? I must've been in a coma while that was happening. Or on ho-ho-holiday.
Im happy Red Velvet got the song.
SNSD doing mature, sophisticated & edgy concepts? I must've been in a coma while that was happening. Or on ho-ho-holiday.
I honestly forgot about Holiday (but they promoted All Night for their mature side) but overall I never heard anyone say that Holiday is their favourite track of SNSD and from what I remember a lot of people were kind of disappointed by not only SM sabotaging them but also the song itself being too childish. I thought more about CMFIYC, Lionheart and You Think. And Holiday is quirky, a bit childish but also kind of glamorous/over the top and girly. Red Flavour is quirky, a bit childish and at the same time girly and kind of tomboyish and more casual overall. SNSD is overall also older than RV and the lyrics fit younger people more. We saw how Hot Summer was made for SNSD vs for f(x). Unless that would have happened for SNSD too with RF, I still think it would have not been 100% fitting
Red Flavor would equally have suited GG! It reminds me a little of Holiday though 
SNSD doing mature, sophisticated & edgy concepts? I must've been in a coma while that was happening. Or on ho-ho-holiday.
Bad girl
Time machine
Mr mr
Lion heart
The list can go on
Holiday was never the 1st pick of snsd
They wanted to do a double title track becauqe they wanted to show the women they become with all night
But didn't want to disappoint people who get cheer up by snsd and their energy that's why they dropped holiday too
Plus as it was their 10th anniversary it was a way to embrace the duality that they had through their entire career
Oh, wow. I love Red Velvet and that song, but SNSD would have taken that song to a different level.
Idk, I can't imagine snsd or anyone else singing red flavor
This song would suit SNSD too but happy it went to Red Velvet. It's one of my favorite red RV song.
Idk, I can't imagine snsd or anyone else singing red flavor
It's my favorite Red Velvet song and as big of a fan of RV as I am, SNSD is SNSD. But regardless, RV killed it.
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
