Among the big4, which company treating their foreign idols the best?

Quote from thebadguy

Or maybe jyp made tzuyu's mom to convince tzuyu to film that hostage apology video by threating that tzuyu's career would end if she does not and she had no other options other than to comply

Tzuyu's mom makes the decision but JYP gets the full blame. How convenient.

Quote from supa

Tzuyu's mom makes the decision but JYP gets the full blame. How convenient.

This flag insident was about to hurt jyp's company and money making, he ain't going to let some foreign woman make desision on how to handle the situation

Quote from supa

Tzuyu's mom makes the decision but JYP gets the full blame. How convenient.

He could have just called tzuyu's mum to korea and gave her ultimatum, either tzuyu apologizes or she getting kicked out of twice, the illusion of choice

Quote from thebadguy

He could have just called tzuyu's mum to korea and gave her ultimatum, either tzuyu apologizes or she getting kicked out of twice, the illusion of choice

idk..

it seems like you're not doing yourself any favors here by saying this.

this only projects what you would do - since this thought process is coming from you.

it's been known that her mom indeed persuaded tzuyu and jyp doesnt have a history of strong arming any idol to do anything - he encourages but for sensitive topics like this, he's known to be very careful.

the fact u dont know this and just write these wild assumptions shows more of YOUR character and not anyone else's.

*

also this is just into Twice's debut. there was no money to be lost if tzuyu didnt apologize.

Seems like the consensus would be SM is the worst but I’m curious who would be the “best” treated foreign idol from SM? Victoria? Lucas?

Would idols like Mark, Wendy and Krystal even be considered a foreign idol?

Quote from lanarene

Seems like the consensus would be SM is the worst but I’m curious who would be the “best” treated foreign idol from SM? Victoria? Lucas?

Would idols like Mark, Wendy and Krystal even be considered a foreign idol?

look at how they treated jessica and krystal . most if not all foreign sm artists leave for greener pasteurs

Seem we all agree one thing, SM is the last

Quote from thebadguy

This flag insident was about to hurt jyp's company and money making, he ain't going to let some foreign woman make desision on how to handle the situation

Of course JYP wanted to do it. Tzuyu's mom also wanted to do it. Tzuyu wanted to do it. They were all on the same page. They were not forced. Her mom was the one that released to the Taiwanese media that she wanted this incident to be resolved quickly. The fastest way is to release the apology which she made the decision to do along with the rest.

YG. Lisa is the #1 female kpop idol worldwide.

Hybe and JYP are good too, but in general, they prioritise group activities over solo activities.

Quote from Flovell

Please no, they will give her a very boring ass songs or straightly terrible songs. Jyp didn't know how to produce a good girl crush and strong concept songs especially for these past few years.

But I am just trying to answer the question, JYPE's track record with foreign idols is pretty good. HYBE is great but may need to take few more years before properly judging them.

Music is trash, girl crush not great, I agree but that's beside the topic.

Lmao these jyp apologists🤡

Quote from Flovell

Pretty good for a new foreign idols to start their careers not for an established idols like Lisa. Beside, idk I don’t know if they can handle her popularity or have enough connections like Yg for example internationally out of korea and japan. It can lead to another mismanagement.

100% agree. HYBE is a superior candidate