Giselle and Ningning k appreciation era, we love it. Winter looks so effortless doing these high notes, and Karina gave the energy necessary ti the encore.

Sooyoung, are you planning to make a thread of the university festival too? The girls sung live there

Totally agree!

I expected nothing less from them actually

On side note (i might be roasted for saying this) but surprisingly Winter is much more stable than Ningning at high notes. Ningning slays when she sings ballad but when come to belting adlibs, seems like Winter is more powerful and consistent (Ningning missed some of the too Spicy notes). Probably this is the reason why Winter is given more adlibs than Ningning while ningning get most lines in ballad/slower songs

Quote from gerrard174

I expected nothing less from them actually

On side note (i might be roasted for saying this) but surprisingly Winter is much more stable than Ningning at high notes. Ningning slays when she sings ballad but when come to belting adlibs, seems like Winter is more powerful and consistent (Ningning missed some of the too Spicy notes). Probably this is the reason why Winter is given more adlibs than Ningning while ningning get most lines in ballad/slower songs

I think Winter in Aespa is like Jessica was in Snsd. Both being very unique vocalists with distinctively strong but delicate vocals.

slay

Quote from gerrard174

I expected nothing less from them actually

On side note (i might be roasted for saying this) but surprisingly Winter is much more stable than Ningning at high notes. Ningning slays when she sings ballad but when come to belting adlibs, seems like Winter is more powerful and consistent (Ningning missed some of the too Spicy notes). Probably this is the reason why Winter is given more adlibs than Ningning while ningning get most lines in ballad/slower songs

i dont think its a secret winter is more stable. i still like ningning more.

Quote from gerrard174

I expected nothing less from them actually

On side note (i might be roasted for saying this) but surprisingly Winter is much more stable than Ningning at high notes. Ningning slays when she sings ballad but when come to belting adlibs, seems like Winter is more powerful and consistent (Ningning missed some of the too Spicy notes). Probably this is the reason why Winter is given more adlibs than Ningning while ningning get most lines in ballad/slower songs

I think this became pretty accepted since Coachella lol Winter belt her notes in a way that looks like lipsync if you don't see the other girls. Leessera is similar, Yunjin technique is better, but Chaewon is more stable than Yunjin

they re so great

Not bad

Quote from neigl

i dont think its a secret winter is more stable. i still like ningning more.

Im glad to hear this fair comment because twitter and youtube are full of ningning fans prepared to roast anyone who say Winter is more stable / deserve her lines.

I kinda like the current arrangement where Ningning is given spotlight for ballads which showcase her vocal more.

Quote from Baeggi

I think this become pretty accepted since Coachella lol Winter belt her notes in a way that looks like lipsync if you don't see the other girls. Leessera is similar, Yunjin technique is better, but Chaewon is more stable than Yunjin

True. Chaewon's experience and stamina really put her over Yunjin in term of stability during performance. Also very evident during encore (antifragile and Unforgiven)