Who fell off hardest? Red Velvet or Itzy?

Quote from Drew_B

Damnit. I forgot that song existed. Why you remind me?

It haunts my sleep at nights, I needed to share the load.

Red Velvet fell?

Don't they sell better with every comeback and sell out all their concerts?

They chart well too, no?

Quote from sonemariam

Red Velvet fell?

Don't they sell better with every comeback and sell out all their concerts?

They chart well too, no?

Indeed. This thread makes no sense, Feel my rhythm is one of the most streamed Kpop songs on Gaon and Melon this year, the reason why they received many nominations for some daesangs in particular at the MMA.

Quote from Drew_B

This thread does make sense. From your reply it looks like you are saying Itzy fell off harder.

Nope. I don't buy this general consensus that a succesful group like Itzy with a large and solid fanbase "fell off" because they are not constantly charting high in Korea when the market is highly oversaturated and competitive these days.

The only thing that has fallen off from Itzy is their Korean charting, from some of their songs. They still had a top 3(?) hit this year regardless and they are absolutely smashing it everywhere else.

Red Velvet hasn't fallen off either. Album sales are up, and their charting is still dependent on what they release - as it always has been.

The only reason it may seem like they've "fallen off" is because there is now a bunch of newer girl groups that are doing better than them over their past few releases.

Quote from Eldeweiss

Indeed. This thread makes no sense, Feel my rhythm is one of the most streamed Kpop songs on Gaon and Melon this year, the reason why they received many nominations for some daesangs in particular at the MMA.

They shamelessly lie.

Red Velvet has longevity. Watch them all stay busy and employed throughout their lives.

They are taking the snsd route.

The only good itzy song is Loco and maybe Wannabe lol

Quote from sonemariam

Red Velvet fell?

Don't they sell better with every comeback and sell out all their concerts?

They chart well too, no?

I totally agree. I'm tired of that the hatred of the former fx fan who opened the thread for Red Velvet has not ended.I don't know when or what happened back then but as Red Velvet will be continues to successful. FMR stayed in Melon for a long time. It's ridiculous that he ignored the FMR success and hit it off from this CB song. Both Queendom and FMR did well, even after Irene's incident, as I recall. Only Birthday didn't catch on in Korea as a song, but the fandom listened to the album fondly.

Both group selling very well.

Quote from Selynn

I totally agree. I'm tired of that the hatred of the former fx fan who opened the thread for Red Velvet has not ended.I don't know when or what happened back then but as Red Velvet will be continues to successful. FMR stayed in Melon for a long time. It's ridiculous that he ignored the FMR success and hit it off from this CB song. Both Queendom and FMR did well, even after Irene's incident, as I recall. Only Birthday didn't catch on in Korea as a song, but the fandom listened to the album fondly.

Both group selling very well.

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

Imagine calling a million seller a flop! The disrespect is next level!

IMO ITZY. Their next comeback will be vital to see if they'll keep growing.

RV has flopped before with One of these nights, RBB, Zimzalabim, and Umpah Umpah. Birthday is nothing new for them. And they always rebound.

ITZY
because I dont feel Red Velvet as a top GG of their Gen(3rd Gen)
they always on the shadow of TWICE and BP

while ITZY at their debut 1st year look like they will be the next JYP GG that will rule the KPOP world
since TWICE
but they already peak at their debut or 1st year
since then they overshadow by all of their contemporary GG of the 4th Gen