Are there any Taiwanese or Hong Kong idols who did not branch out to Ch and don't post mandated content supporting 1Ch
-
-
-
Does Tzuyu really count though? In her apology she acknowledged that Taiwan was a part of China.
-
-
Does Tzuyu really count though? In her apology she acknowledged that Taiwan was a part of China.
She was forced to say that as a minor and has she ever had any activities in China since then?
-
She was forced to say that as a minor and has she ever had any activities in China since then?
But isn't that what people here say about Chinese idols in kpop...that they're forced to post pro CCP stuff on SNS. As for activities in China, she can't because she's still on the CCP blacklist.
-
She was forced to say that as a minor and has she ever had any activities in China since then?
It was obviously forced in that vid
But since she opened her individual ig account she hasn't posted anything
-
But isn't that what people here say about Chinese idols in kpop...that they're forced to post pro CCP stuff on SNS. As for activities in China, she can't because she's still on the CCP blacklist.
The two weren't even similar situations. She was actually supporting her country and was forced to retract it.
-
Politic in this forum? Well there is one China. That's a fact. China recognize that(their side) and Taiwan recognize that(their side), US recognize that, the world recognize that. Problem is US play too side of the same coin officially recognize mainland China is legitimate while also act in way as Taiwan is independent(strategic partner).
-
-
Tzuyu, a minor, in a foreign country was being roasted alive for lifting her own country's flag.
Her face is still blurred out in china and the only time she gets support is when she goes viral for her visuals/look alikes/airport arrivals or departures. She has legit never uploaded or spoken anything pro ccp before or since that apology(which is not even something she should be apologising for lbr). That tells you all you need to know about her stance.
-
I am very curious about this as well.
I cannot count the amount of times Chinese idols disappointed me by promoting the Chinese propaganda, but I am even more sad about Hong Kong and Taiwanese idols doing it.
Really Jackson Wang and Fei are propaganda tools and really love their genociadal dictatorship was devastating.
Did the NCT members post something btw?
-
-
Does Tzuyu really count though? In her apology she acknowledged that Taiwan was a part of China.
Yes she really counts.
She was forced by JYPE to say that, and you know it. People claim Chinese idols are "forced" to promote Chinese propaganda, but they don't literally have their employer standing them in front of a camera, handing them a script and making them recite it hostage style. That's what happened to Tzuyu (something JYPE has never taken the proper heat for.) It's not comparable. She's also never voiced support for mainland China at any other time.Politic in this forum? Well there is one China. That's a fact. China recognize that(their side) and Taiwan recognize that(their side), US recognize that, the world recognize that. Problem is US play too side of the same coin officially recognize mainland China is legitimate while also act in way as Taiwan is independent(strategic partner).
Because it can. China bullies all of its smaller neighbors, but it won't be bullying the US.
-
Tzuyu, a minor, in a foreign country was being roasted alive for lifting her own country's flag.
Her face is still blurred out in china and the only time she gets support is when she goes viral for her visuals/look alikes/airport arrivals or departures. She has legit never uploaded or spoken anything pro ccp before or since that apology(which is not even something she should be apologising for lbr). That tells you all you need to know about her stance.
…err nothing? If anything it proves that people don’t post pro China unless they have to promote in China.
So we don’t know if she would change if given a chance to make money over there post her time in twice maybe some years from now.
-
This is pure conjecture. You can say we don't know for certain she wouldn't do it, but there's zero reason to believe she would support the CCP to make money in China. She's never attempted it or even shown any signs that she would do such a thing. She's never actually promoted in China for that matter. JYPE made her "apologize" because they wanted Twice to promote in China, not Tzuyu. They still got denied.
-
Because it can. China bullies all of its smaller neighbors, but it won't be bullying the US.
China's no saint but US foreign policy is greatest threat to world peace. The Afghanistan debacle which we had no business starting, the Ukraine situation, Pelosi's visit are all destabilizing actions instigated by US. The fabrication of genocide pushed by US government and western medias have everyone believing this such as earlier commenter. The fabricated evidence don't hold up to scrutiny. It's part of their manufactured consent for confrontation with China. You are getting your source from one side and so not surprised you are shaped by western propaganda. The reality is not what you think.
-
This is pure conjecture. You can say we don't know for certain she wouldn't do it, but there's zero reason to believe she would support the CCP to make money in China. She's never attempted it or even shown any signs that she would do such a thing. She's never actually promoted in China for that matter. JYPE made her "apologize" because they wanted Twice to promote in China, not Tzuyu. They still got denied.
Tzuyu's parents are the ones that wanted her to do it too.
-
She could or she couldn't. Let's not try her for something that hasn't even happened yet. My point still stands that there has been no sign of support either before or after the apology incident when other idols, even from her very own company, didn't hestitate to be openly pro china.
-
China's no saint but US foreign policy is greatest threat to world peace. The Afghanistan debacle which we had no business starting, the Ukraine situation, Pelosi's visit are all destabilizing actions instigated by US. The fabrication of genocide pushed by US government and western medias have everyone believing this such as earlier commenter. The fabricated evidence don't hold up to scrutiny. It's part of their manufactured consent for confrontation with China. You are getting your source from one side and so not surprised you are shaped by western propaganda. The reality is not what you think.
The US harms world peace, but it objectively maintains it much more so. We would have had several more world wars by now without US hegemony preventing them. It's not at all the "greatest threat" it's made out to be.
The "debacle" in Afghanistan was started by the Afghans harboring Bin Laden & Al-Qaeda after 9/11. If they had cooperated, there would have been no invasion.
Russia started the Ukraine situation, and Russia alone. They have no business in Ukraine. If you're going to blame the US for invading other countries, I expect you to at least be consistent.
Pelosi's visit was destabilizing, but it also sent a message. Do you see China actually doing anything but posturing? Nope. Because they now know they can't get away with it.
If the genocide you're referring to is the Uyghurs, the evidence is not fabricated and it's rather disgusting that someone would suggest as much. Don't try playing the "your views are shaped by propaganda, but I'm totally unbiased" card. You very clearly are anything but.
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
