Here is the vocal girl group of 4th generation

Quote from SooYoung

it was gayo daejun performance on the sheet

but even on this stage you can hear it's live

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

LOOK AT THEM ROOKIE GROUP OF ALMOST 6 MONTHS Winter and Ningx2 killed the bridge I'm sooooo proud of them

Quote from bartkun

how could it age badly when they didn't made comeback yet :>?

I will see and I hope I will like their on-stage performances

Yeah you said they never sang live with on stage choreo even staff had to release the proof, aespa are the real deal sis

The performed MR which is LIVE now people will stop downplaying aespa

i like StayC's vocals cause all of them have so distinct vocal colors

Aespa are best

We very clearly don't have enough perf to compare Stayc, Pk and Weeekly right now. And Aespa of course has very little live perf.

Quote from SooYoung

we can't do anything if other favs used them to average/below average vocal performance

that they can't make the difference between live and lipsync, unless their voices aren't great or screaming in the mic

I see nothing but truth in what you said we knew our favs sang live, others now know, proof is there, it's day and night.

Whether people continue to downplay them, that's their personal business, aespa is coming either way

Next level  

Im so confused because stayc sounded out of tune to me most of the time ????

Am I the only one hearing that ?

All of the 4th gen groups mentioned in this thread aren't impressive vocally at all tbh.

No one in the 4th gen is strong enough to be called a vocal group imo, they're all leagues below mamamoo, RV, Sistar, snsd, 15& etc. And that's ok, they don't need to be vocal groups lol.

Quote from HyungHunter

All of the 4th gen groups mentioned in this thread aren't impressive vocally at all tbh.

No one in the 4th gen is strong enough to be called a vocal group imo, they're all leagues below mamamoo, RV, Sistar, snsd, 15& etc. And that's ok, they don't need to be vocal groups lol.

Aespa are vocal group

Quote from HyungHunter

All of the 4th gen groups mentioned in this thread aren't impressive vocally at all tbh.

No one in the 4th gen is strong enough to be called a vocal group imo, they're all leagues below mamamoo, RV, Sistar, snsd, 15& etc. And that's ok, they don't need to be vocal groups lol.

They dont need to be as technically great as the ones you mentioned. But at least they should hold their tunes. I also consider Purple Kiss a vocal group the same as weeeekly tbh.

And tbh groups like RV, has very median average, it’s because only one singer truly has the expertise, the rest falls short. That still doesn’t disqualify them as vocal group tho, they still are one of the best there is.

Quote from HyungHunter

All of the 4th gen groups mentioned in this thread aren't impressive vocally at all tbh.

No one in the 4th gen is strong enough to be called a vocal group imo, they're all leagues below mamamoo, RV, Sistar, snsd, 15& etc. And that's ok, they don't need to be vocal groups lol.

So this is not impressive vocally for you ? And they're not a vocal group ?