Posts by pchromo4

Quote from uwuwu-98

I wonder how Melon is going to handle the Kpop demon junters artists regarding the awards. The system is simple, if the name of the artist is in the song it counts for their points, but all these songs have many singers with some of them not even being real and they're accumulating an amount of streams that would probably guarantee bonsangs for several of them.

For example "Kpop Demon Hunter Cast" is in almost all the songs so if the situation continues like this they're probably going to be the 2nd or 3rd artist with the most points this year below G-Dragon and maybe Ive. But it's not just them since "HUNTR/X", "Saga Boys", "Ejae", "Andrew Choi"... Are all included in several songs and many are becoming hits.

This added to the super weak year we're having with barely any artist getting more than one hit and with low ULs could make a situation with several of these "singers" into the top 10. I assume they'd lose the voting and just leave 1 or 2 among the winners, or Melon could straight up ignore their existence and not nominate them, but the situation is funny anyway lmao.

Oh, and the album might be the album with the most points too, we'll see.

Display More

Usually OST songs are disqualified from bonsangs, no? So why would it be different here.

when I actually agree with one of yama's hills that he's willing to die on

Really not easy to tour as a solo! Happy for hobi~

Sorry, haven't read the full thread because I got bored after page 3 lol.

TBH, I agree with Yama's premise (SKZ cannot be considered a GOAT because they do not have legitimate hits), but the hypocrisy is what gets to me

Here is the consistent logical thinking of someone who isn't biased:

- SKZ can't be considered a GOAT because they do not have any legitimate hits, either globally or domestically.

- Blackpink can't be considered a GOAT because they do not have any daesangs despite coming from a Big3 agency (which historically received the bulk of daesangs)

- NJZ can't be considered a GOAT (yet) because they do not have an touring data even though it happened against their will (pending for future since they actually have the greatest chance to change this)

But Yama will fight tooth and nail against one of them even though they all assume the same premise - there's certain key criteria that is considered "necessary" for GOAT status and the overwhelming success of other criteria cannot compensate for the absence of a key criteria.

Quote from SooYoung

but where is the media coverage ? news anchor talking about it ??

so yes my point still stand that they are just making this issue take such big proportion cuz it's karina

did the PPP leader give Beenzino a shout out like they did for Karina? Or did a popular conservative talking head also praise Beenzino like they did for Karina? Of course part of the controversy is that Karina has a lot of popularity/influence, which is why the PPP immediately grabbed onto her supposed endorsement. SM and Karina's delayed response didn't help. But you're missing the point of why some Koreans are disappointed in her. Either she wanted to promote the PPP or she's completely clueless about the political climate in SK right now. Neither option is great. It's not deserving of being cancelled or witch-hunted but being obtuse about her actions also isn't helpful.

I doubt this will affect their comeback. PPP is pretty popular in SK (almost 50% of population), there will just be more discontent among some of their female fans and obviously the hannam goddess tag might follow her for a bit. Groups like QWER openly pander to incels, so clearly there is a market there as well.

Quote from NmiXXSupremacist

And Jeongyeon?. Until her issue with her back she always had the more stable vocals in the encores. Come on, Jeongyeon is easily more talented than Jisso.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Yep, I agree, a team of Jihyo/Momo/Nayeon/Jeongyeon > current BP but I still think Jisoo is a better performer than Sana and Dahyun (and maybe Mina/Tzuyu).

Jihyo > Rose

Lisa > Momo (also for vocals)

Nayeon = Jennie

Jisoo > the most filler members (you can pick)

So BP wins for me but Twice would win if you just took their top 4 members.

Quote from Dinner

What did that fan do,I wasn't following kpop that time

a female fan went viral during the protests (against the conservative party) that said "I'm marching for a better south korea for karina to live in"

Either Karina wanted to sneakily give a shoutout to the conservative party or she's completely clueless/ignorant/blind to the political upheaval happening in her country right now. tbh either option deserves criticism (within reason). I just feel bad for the karina fan who went viral during the protests.

If the kakao founder wasn't above jail time then neither is bang! they better get his ass

IU released an MV for "Beauty"!!

we don't even have the objection results, y'all are so dramatic

This album is so nostalgic! I love how she re-arranged all the songs.

I've obsessed with "last scene" and "a beautiful person". Really hoping one of those 2 has an MV.

Hope this is a more rock-focused album!

Happy birthday IU

Been waiting forever!!! Love her Flower Bookmark series.

Why are you acting like this was IU's first time nominated at Baeksang? This was her 4th nomination, and she didn't pull back from either singing or acting any of the previous 3 times.

Bye Tatty, we often disagreed and I found a lot of what you said distasteful but you were at least always genuine in your support of your favs, and I hope you're able to find a better environment. I trust that NJs will one day return and continue to live out their dreams!