Can members who had a kid or married comeback to their groups ?

we all know that agency use this the weird relation that fans have to their favs, when they almost feel like they are dating them to promote their groups

that's why they are playing on the fanservice, and that's why groups doing a lot of fanservice are usually pretty popular

but this whole "relation" for some kpop fans lie on the fake image, that idols are your friends/BG/GF, that they are single and you feel special to them

but when members of kpop groups have a baby or get marry this ideal of the image of Idol suddenly break

that's why a lot of idols leave their groups when they'll become parent or marry

and there's some case when idol are ready to comeback in the group but fans are against it, because they feel betray like in the case of Sungmin from Super junior

we don't see a lot of active group who are popular promoting with a marry man or a father

but lately we saw this happening much more, with Bobby and Chen for example marrying someone and becoming father

do you think that these type of idols have a chance to go back to their group like normal and be accepted by fans ?

or do you think fans will most likely be against it, and these members will unofficially leave the group like Sungmin ?

Quote from Hyunjiinii

i dont think they should come back bcos it is irresponsible to not look after their family as being a kpop idol takes alot of work.

well they are not looking after their family by making millions of dollar promoting as Kpop idol ? '-'

Quote from Hyunjiinii

that is a good point

maybe if they from a popular group since they have more fans to forgive them, but i think if it is an idol from a lesser known group then they are in trouble.

well Sungmin was from Suju , a big group

and he can't come back in the group since he marry his wife

fans were even still mad about it when he release a solo song in last august

Quote from nevermindmejin

It will be easier for BGs but GGs definitely a no no

agree

i think if a GG member comeback she'll get a lot more hate than a BG members

considering that i think people would attack her saying " she's on stage when she should take care of her baby" , "who's taking care of her baby if she's on stage"

meanwhile the BG members would have less problems since people would just say that he is to make money for his family

even if it by using the money of his fan that he "betray"

especially in a very traditionnal country like Korea, where they still have this image that the woman take care of the home, the kids and her husband when he come home

and the husband should be the one to bring the money home

Quote from bobsyouruncle

i mean so many older gen idols who are married have had comebacks recently in their groups (some whilst pregnant) so

like who ?

After school members ? they didn't make a comeback it was just a special performance

or like SES for their anniversary ?

that's why i mention active group

because people tend to be much more okay when it's a group who's no longer active considering that their fandom move on to other groups

Quote from bobsyouruncle

both but also theres lee hyori whos married and had a comeback in a different group so idk i guess it depends on your image beforehand.

well it was a special project group

it's not a real group, and people are already use to hyori, she's consider as an old idol

that's why people don't really care, she doesn't have a fanbase anymore

she rely on the public know, and the public doesn't really care about this

it's more the fanbase who have problems with this