if SNSD and BTS are on the same gen or time, who will be bigger?

Snsd

me

If it’s during SNSD’s heyday (is it 2010? Sorry too lazy to google), it think it will be SNSD. But if it’s now, it will be BTS. Both are perfect for their own eras

"Great question"

Nice question

Quote from supertiffany

Yeah

but if they were both in the same time together

because I read many saying SNSD is so phenomenal that they were able to beat boy groups

which is used against blackpink, saying BP isnt a record breaking gg because they didnt slay bg like snsd

Display More

I think what nevermindmejin was saying is :

- If these two groups were active during second gens, BTS probably wouldn't have succeed like they did, as they weren't Big Three, and mostly used social medias to gather a large fanbase, which wasn't really a thing in 2007-10. SNSD would have been clear winner considering their success.

- If these two groups were active during third gens, then BTS would have still won against SNSD in my opinion. For the sole reason that they are winning against everyone anyway.

Honestly this opinion about BP is unfair. They are slaying BG too, and there is no shame in not 'slaying' BTS, no kpop group can do it, boys or girls.

Quote from supertiffany

Yeah

but if they were both in the same time together

because I read many saying SNSD is so phenomenal that they were able to beat boy groups

which is used against blackpink, saying BP isnt a record breaking gg because they didnt slay bg like snsd

Display More

Yeah that’s what I meant. If BTS and SNSD are at the same time in 2010, it will be SNSD. If SNSD are in the prime now, it still will be BTS. I think both groups are perfect for their own respective time.

I didn’t know that we are talking about BP here. If so, why don’t we take BTS out of the equation and ask, if BP exist together with SNSD, which group will be bigger?

Better question should be BP vs SNSD or BB vs BTS

Quote from supertiffany

if SNSD and BTS are on the same gen or time, who will be bigger?

Each Generation has their time Periode of success. You can't them Mixed Up.

if its on 2010's SNSD and if its nowadays/2020's bts

I don't know what you mean who will be bigger when it is obvious bts achievements now when compared to snsd at their prime is still bigger

We don't even know bts peak yet but they are still bigger than any kpop group that has ever existed generation aside