TWICE "THIS IS FOR" vs BLACKPINK "JUMP" (Fairer Poll Edition)

It looks really fresh and different from what Blackpink usually brings visually, so I’m excited! Dave Meyers has worked with top artists from Britney Spears to Janet Jackson, so I just know he and the girls are going to bring something really special to the table!

I think upon first listen I prefer jump

I gotta go with Jump between the two.

They are both fine, nothing special, but THIS IS FOR edges JUMP slightly.

This is the worst period in K-pop history. They are both terrible. Viviz is the only saving grace right now.

If we are in a club then I would prefer Blackpink songs. However, I don’t live in a club and so I prefer Twices song. That said, I think Twice song is too short and that’s a shame. Also there are some elements I do not think match overall but it’s a good song.

Jump is different from what BP has done before. That’s doesn’t mean it’s great but it’s decent. I think it’s meant for a club or something and I think it does that well.

Even though I normally not like Blackpink. I voted for jump. Both songs are a blop for me. Now I'm going to listen to H1-KEY, Viviz and Fromis_9 instead.

Quote from ThePhantomThief

Epic 3rd gen gg battle.

Which one do you prefer?

Now with a fairer poll taking in all sides, not just a negative leaning shit post.

Thanks for this.

I'm the one vote for "I like both" so far

just me or the mvs are really bad

Jump.

This is for sounds like an itzy and nmixx song mixed together. Flop for me

I like both actually, but I want to listen to This is For a little more after listening to both songs

Both are bad! Nothing EPIC in these, also where's the BATTLE?

It's basically The Chipmunks vs Tiesto girls.😅

TWICE - Takedown cover charting better than their own song, and that kinda proves my point about how shit JYP is at producing.

Overall, TWICE is better, and the MV didn't make me throw up, like JUMP did.

JUMP MV should be banned from existence, and I'm not even kidding.

Also, wonder if Anti-AI people will boycott Blackpink's MV as well.

They're both bad, in their own ways. Time to stop hyping up this "battle."

Quote from David33

It's basically The Chipmunks vs Tiesto girls.😅

Chipmunks? You only listened to the album preview, didn't you? Be honest.

Quote from Popper-of-Ks

They're both bad, in their own ways. Time to stop hyping up this "battle."

Chipmunks? You only listened to the album preview, didn't you? Be honest.

Mate, I don't write reviews based on previews, I listened to the whole goddamn 2 minute.🤣

Compare their voices in "Takedown" and in this song. In this one, they sound unnatural.

I didn't rate the album, because I didn't listen to it yet, but I will later when I will get better, because Blackpink - JUMP literally made me throw up. No, I'm not kidding.

I almost had an epileptic seizure.

When I say: Fck with all the companies that don't give us a WARNING before the video, they should be shut down, I mean it!

Pun intended.

Quote from David33

Mate, I don't write reviews based on previews, I listened to the whole goddamn 2 minute.🤣

Compare their voices in "Takedown" and in this song. In this one, they sound unnatural.

I didn't rate the album, because I didn't listen to it yet, but I will later when I will get better, because Blackpink - JUMP literally made me throw up. No, I'm not kidding.

I almost had an epileptic seizure.

When I say: Fck with all the companies that don't give us a WARNING before the video, they should be shut down, I mean it!

Pun intended.

Display More

I have no idea what "chipmunks" you're referring to. I think you might need immediate medical attention, because you're hearing things.

For what it's worth, I had a similar reaction to Jump, but I'm not epileptic.

Quote from Popper-of-Ks

I have no idea what "chipmunks" you're referring to. I think you might need immediate medical attention, because you're hearing things.

For what it's worth, I had a similar reaction to Jump, but I'm not epileptic.

The chipmunks might be a bit of overexaggeration, but I've seen you complaining about the overused autotune as well this week too.

There's like ZERO need for autotune. Jihyo sounds unnatural the most, I think, but I only heard it once.

Quote from David33

The chipmunks might be a bit of overexaggeration, but I've seen you complaining about the overused autotune as well this week too.

There's like ZERO need for autotune. Jihyo sounds unnatural the most, I think, but I only heard it once.

I complained about the "autotune" in the album preview, where most of the tracks were sped up, hence all the distorted vocals. They don't sound like that on the album, and I don't hear it here.

I have no idea why they did it, but tbh I would've preferred the preview versions of some of these songs, minus the vocal distortion, but they all would've been 1 minute long.

Right now, I'm enjoying Jump a lot more. It's very catchy.

This is for feels a bit bland for me.