Is it safe to say SM's new girl group Hearts2Hearts is vocally weak?

Quote from autumnleaf_soshi

guys it's ok to roast me

a clown deserves a good roasting

Display More

I know you’re not serious and using reverse psychology to get everyone talking about H2H are the girls talented? Can they sing? Can they dance? If anything you’re bring more attention to them

isn't too soon to tell?

since Flo produced their debut song, I'm pretty sure the members are as capable as SNSD members (meaning at least 4-5 members can sing) . Not as talented as aespa or tvxq tho but won't be worse than riize/wish/wayv

Damn, didn't even give the girlies a chance to sing . Who knows, maybe SM is hiding their biggest strength: vocals

Quote from autumnleaf_soshi

has the departure of the Godfather of Kpop from SM (Lee Soo Man selfmate ) ending the vocal dominant reputation that SM had for the past 3 decades this year?

if they are good vocally then LSM's legacy lives on

if they aren't well I didn't recruit them!!!

I wished sm made promo videos showing their talents too, like nmixx did. But I don't think that mean the girls are just visuals, Juun is an amazing dancer and they didn't release a dance video.

As predicted it’s not safe to say H2H are alrady getting praised for their vocals in the teaser alone

Quote from autumnleaf_soshi

has the departure of the Godfather of Kpop from SM (Lee Soo Man selfmate ) ending the vocal dominant reputation that SM had for the past 3 decades this year?

will H2H be the one?

The LSM kick is obviously affecting SM in many ways. They've lost a lot of talent and are no longer the SM everyone knew during the golden era of Kpop. LSM kept the nest together somehow. I won't be surprised if it affects their vocals and quality of new idols. Actually, I expect a decline so I guess I'm waiting to be surprised.

Quote from autumnleaf_soshi

how about now tho

what has changed? am I missing something?

Well, from the few snippets where they are singing live like on radio broadcasts, one could at least determine that Hearts2Hearts members can sing well live, with the excellent vocal coaches that SM (presumably still?) have, nothing less should be expected.

So I don't think it's safe to say they're vocally weak, you would need more live performances to draw such conclusions, also to determine at what ability level their vocal line is.

Compared to Taeyeon, Wendy and MAMAMOO? Yes! Compared to other 5th gen groups, not really. They only released 2 songs, and hardly did any REAL LIVE performance, so there's no reason to judge them.

From what I've heard, they're good singers. Well, some of them.