Unpopular opinion - JYP should have debuted Nmixx in 5th gen?

ive been saying for a long time they should just re-debut nmixx as a 5th gen group! finally someone gets it

Wouldn't make a difference.

Unpopular opinion: NMIXX was doomed the moment Jinni's departure was announced.

Quote from foreveraespaaa

You can’t just re debut a group unless they add new members

well NJZ is, but those are different circumstances.

But I do agree with you, I think nmixx could've been more successful had they debuted later, closer to 5th gen. Though they did have a rough start with the reception of O.O (which I actually love) and losing a member.

Quote from foreveraespaaa

The Butterfly effect! Had they debuted in recent times/5th gen Jinni could have stayed

Yeah maybe but I have not seen a group who completely recovered after a member left.

It also depends on WHY Jinni left because I'm not believing that personal circumstances bs.

Quote from CaraFIMIE

Yeah maybe but I have not seen a group who completely recovered after a member left.

dont you stan a group that recovered after a member left? lol

I don't think it'd work

Unless it was an accidental hit

o.o is timeless

Quote from Tru-Multistan

dont you stan a group that recovered after a member left? lol

I know but not exactly. During their controversy, I saw many people saying that Garam should never have left because LSF apparently needed someone who was in the trainee system for a long time and had "actual talent." I'm very sure that sentiment will follow them around for the rest of their careers because some people are relentless lol.

Even SNSD hasn't fully recovered since Jessica left. Momoland and TVXQ fell apart. I could prolly name more but only (G)i-dle has shown signs of recovery and even then, it doesn't seem like the members themselves have moved on from it, completely.

Quote from foreveraespaaa

I think the leading rumor was she was caught leaving a hotel with her boyfriend? Which isn’t bad but during the rookie days can have bad publicity

I really hope that wasn’t the reason they kicked her out

I hope so too cuz that would be an extremely lousy reason to ruin a young girl's dreams over.

Quote from foreveraespaaa

Companies do have strict dating rules especially for

Big 3/4 espeically rookies so wouldn’t be surprised

I mean, I understand why the dating rule is in place but I still don't see how it is worth kicking the member that is responsible, out of the group.

Quote from CaraFIMIE

I know but not exactly. During their controversy, I saw many people saying that Garam should never have left because LSF apparently needed someone who was in the trainee system for a long time and had "actual talent." I'm very sure that sentiment will follow them around for the rest of their careers because some people are relentless lol.

Even SNSD hasn't fully recovered since Jessica left. Momoland and TVXQ fell apart. I could prolly name more but only (G)i-dle has shown signs of recovery and even then, it doesn't seem like the members themselves have moved on from it, completely.

good points, definitely fair to say that a group never completely recovers, but at least they are still doing well!

I dunno what goes on behind the scenes but maybe JYPE had some sort of imperative to debut them - cost of training, business decisions etc etc

Quote from CaraFIMIE

I know but not exactly. During their controversy, I saw many people saying that Garam should never have left because LSF apparently needed someone who was in the trainee system for a long time and had "actual talent." I'm very sure that sentiment will follow them around for the rest of their careers because some people are relentless lol.

Even SNSD hasn't fully recovered since Jessica left. Momoland and TVXQ fell apart. I could prolly name more but only (G)i-dle has shown signs of recovery and even then, it doesn't seem like the members themselves have moved on from it, completely.

I would disagree with you with regards to Gidle my friend

if one looks at the numbers then one would say Gidle post Soojin has arguably done better than pre Soojin

but obviously that depends on what one considers "recovers"

Quote from Tru-Multistan

good points, definitely fair to say that a group never completely recovers, but at least they are still doing well!

Yeah I can only hope that the group does well and gets better.

Quote from selfmate

I would disagree with you with regards to Gidle my friend

if one looks at the numbers then one would say Gidle post Soojin has arguably done better than pre Soojin

but obviously that depends on what one considers "recovers"

Yeah, I'm not considering "recovers" in that regard.

I mean 'recovers' in the sense that the group's synergy has been lost (at least, imo)

Quote from CaraFIMIE

Yeah I can only hope that the group does well and gets better.

Yeah, I'm not considering "recovers" in that regard.

I mean 'recovers' in the sense that the group's synergy has been lost (at least, imo)

gotcha makes sense