How would you rank these top 4th gen girl group hit songs?

Quote from YamaChwan

I'm kind of side eyeing the decision to place Love Dive and Next Level above Ditto.

What's the reasoning?

If you dont wanna wait for uwuwu's reply, i gave an S tier explanation on my post, you can check it out

Too many songs

You should have made it simple

Quote from YamaChwan

It's a fun thought exercise! Just give a quick list ASAP. Hurry up. Don't be lazy.

Exactly

Hell I've given like four or five versions of the list!

Maybe about to do version 6

Domestically,

1. Hype Boy

2. Next Level

3. Love Dive

4. Ditto

5. Dalla Dalla

The top 5 songs tbh. Just so know that NewJeans and IVE hits makes up rest of the list with few Gidle, Le Sserafim, aespa songs in between.

Globally, Cupid, OMG, Super Shy, DITTO, Hype Boy, Pop/Stars, Wannabe, Antifragile, Perfect Night, Queencard, Attention, Love Dive etc. The list just going to be NewJeans songs overall dominating it.

Why the YummyChan?

Quote from YamaChwan

Tell us how you REALLY feel

I feel ranking stuff by "popularity" is a silly childish thing with no real point or value to it done by insecure types who want to get validation through the cute music done by cute girls they like, hence why I'm just giving Excel spreadsheet randomised function lists, because thats how much worth it has.

More fun, for me, is ranking the songs in order of personal preference and enjoyment.

That's how I REALLY feel.

Quote from YamaChwan

Quote from icyruios

Ryujin shoulder dance still live rent free in my mind

I think it's their biggest international hit

Yup that’s why I’m surprised it wasn’t a big local hit

Quote from YamaChwan

I'm kind of side eyeing the decision to place Love Dive and Next Level above Ditto.

What's the reasoning?

2022 had so many gg big hits that might make us don't realize how big some of them really were. LD is without any doubt the 2nd biggest post Dynamite song in Korea just below Hype boy. With Next level i make the comparison with Tomboy, I just feel it was slighty bigger, and imo Ditto is a Tomboy but in a year with less competition so it seems bigger. We also have to look from what were the groups coming from, Ditto jumped to the top of the charts because of NJ's huge debut but Next level had to rise, and rising it performed better than any other song released that year in the long run apart from IU's.

Also Ditto is still in the top 20 of the charts, if it continues having crazy longevity it can go higher ofc, I want to see how it charts the upcoming winters.

And the most important thing, I have no idea, we don't even live in Korea, I just try to be objective with the data I have and what I know about charts but it could be wrong perfectly lmao. Still more objective than the other lists I've seen in the thread.

Quote from YamaChwan

But I've been giving the board a break from my threads for Christmas week. Come on! Let's start the new year the right way

With a fight!