2024 Flop Song Battle : CAKE vs BADDIE vs BATTER UP

Cake is the worst of these, sorry.

Baddie is okay.

Batter Up is actually decently catchy, just underwhelming compared to expectations.

Worst to Best : Cake > Baddie > Batter Up

From best to worst imo :

1. Batter Up (Not my type of songs but I dont understand the level of hate neither, it sounds like a lot other YG songs that people hyped a lot)

2. Cake

3. Baddie

I thought I had to vote for my favorite so I voted Batter Up.

If I had to vote for the worst I would choose Baddie. I dislike how monotonous, repetitive and uninteresting it is to me.

Cake with terrible vocals

Quote from Daisy_Queen

I voted before I read the end, I'm so sorry baddie😭

youll be reincarnated as a cat in the next life for your grave sins

I did a wrong vote

To me cake is the worst one : JYP has blood on his hands

Baddie is okay and BU is a bop but underwhelming.

Cake and Batter Up are really terrible songs. Baddie is just really mediocre.

1. Cake
2. Battter Up
3. Baddie

1. Baddie - A flop comeback. Domestically the ULs are 50% lower than their previous comeback. It means they have lost 1/2 their support. Even worse globally, where there is the potential for massive growth, since none of their 3 title tracks ranked in any of the many global charts, they have declined globally while all the other leading groups are still growing.

2. Cake - ok song. Not bad, not great. They were the trend a couple of years ago, but everyone has moved on.

3. Batter Up - it did what it needed to do, to get BP to renew as a group.

from worst to least bad

Cake - the repeating 'cake cake cake cake' part is hella annoying makes the song unlistenable to me

>>> Batter Up - sounds dated and boring those edits that people posted here from twitter actually sounded waaaay better

>>>>>>>Baddie - underwhelming and repetitive but at least I like parts of it and the chorus did grew on me but still their worst title track to me