rosé is a 4th gen soloist

Quote from bartkun

nope it's just stupid...

even with achievements Moonbyul and Solar are always put in 3rd gen soloist charts/tables/summaries...

by who? because the one and only headline i saw about solar debut was that she’s a “debuting in 4th gen as a soloist with her track “spit it out”” or whatever it’s called

people are really getting pressed about

1) old news

2) people calling rosie a “3rd and 4th gen idol” instead of only 3rd gen

Quote from bartkun

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

her solo debut was in early 2018. that IS 3rd gen.

why do you guys act like 4th gen started in 2017

Quote from teume4ever

rosie is 3rd gen whether you like it or not and will be grouped with jennie, hwasa, moonbyul etc cause they all debuted around the same time. it's unfair to compare her to people who are actually debuting in 4th gen with no prior fanbase.

i know she’s 3rd gen. but she’s also 4th gen.

it doesn’t matter what you think is fair (nice to see what your real problem with this is. you’re worried about her dominance since she has a prior fanbase)

it doesn’t matter if you think it’s unfair. she’s a 3rd and 4th gen idol. you’re so focused on petty stuff like grouping people into categories to compare achievements to “like-experienced people” and preserve the curve for your 4th gen faves.

get over it. it doesn’t matter. that’s how it works and has always worked. your part of any AND EVERY generation you have a proper debut in. this is hers. lisa and jisoo will also be 4th gen soloists (if yg doesn’t fuck it up)