given taken should have been a txt song

no

tbh it probably was a TxT reject. I think it fits their sound. Very whimsical and somewhat fairytale like.

Quote from ellenote

if i was they would be billionaires. I am smart.

Personally I feel like Given-Taken fits Enhypen better than TXT

I think the concept doesn’t match, the public likes them more by doing pop color

i kinda glad that it wasn't their comeback song

bluehour is better

Absolutely not

Quote from ellenote

Yes. Imagine a horror concept from them. Imagine it

We already kinda had one with Eternally tho...

Quote from ellenote

Yes but I want a horror concept for TXT they would suit it so much.

Actually after thinking deeply about it, I actually feel that if Given-Taken was given to TXT, it would sound & look probably pretty cool. Yeonjun's and Taehyun's vocals, Soobin's falsetto and Beomgyu's and Huening Kai's dancing.... I can imagine it

Quote from Sara-M

Actually after thinking deeply about it, I actually feel that if Given-Taken was given to TXT, it would sound & look probably pretty cool. Yeonjun's and Taehyun's vocals, Soobin's falsetto and Beomgyu's and Huening Kai's dancing.... I can imagine it

Stop that

Quote from ellenote

Blue hour is my least fav.

my ranking is

1. Runaway

2. Blue Hour

3. CYSM

4. Crown

I depise crown with a burning passion. Its the single reason why i didn't stan txt immediately.

Quote from dryheat

Stop that

It would sound cool, being honest :)

Quote from ellenote

1. Cat and dog. We all know it.

I prefer Crown, it remains superior

Quote from Sara-M

It would sound cool, being honest :)

I don't see it tbh

Enhypen did it well tho

Quote from ellenote

1. Cat and dog. We all know it.

omg yes a cat dog enthusiast

I'm sick and tired of that song getting slandered left and right by moas. Its such a bop and my favorite song off of the dream chapter star album. Maybe you do have taste...

Quote from dryheat

I don't see it tbh

Enhypen did it well tho

That is true though.... like the concept really fit the members

TXT already had eternity album for dark horror fantasy concept.

I googled the lyrics, the song was really made for En, it fits perfectly with their storyline with red eyes, fangs, etc.

Quote from Sara-M

That is true though.... like the concept really fit the members

Quote from ellenote

Yeah I love the song and MV. lol moas call it a furry song. It is cute and suited their concept back then.

You should know how TXT feel about Cat & Dog

Thread

TXT are Cat & Dog antis

No... they're not dislike cats or dogs, Soobin has and adorable dog named Sean. And Taehyun has cute cat named Hobak.

I'm talking about this fur anthem
youtu.be/NaKrke1EL1A

Look how they confused why Moa suddenly gotten cheer up when they performing Cat & Dog on Fanlive
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/16517/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/16519/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/16520/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/16522/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/16524/
…

Nakayuki

Mar 10th 2021

Quote from ellenote

Yes but I want a horror concept for TXT they would suit it so much.

are you living in 2019 lol, we had a whole tdc: eternity and that's my fav era of theirs

Anyways, anticipate THE CHAOS CHAPTER

Also, I'm not trying to drag anyone but given-taken would have been their first skip for me if it was a txt song

Quote from ellenote

Yes I know LOL I wanted a darker eerie horror concept not boy crush. I cant wait for the chaos chapter

But only Blue Hour was boy crush, star and magic never were? And my second fav is magic

Quote from ellenote

I was referring to CYSM. Run away is magic teen crush and crown is just teen crush.

I don't see them as crush but you do you

Quote from ellenote

They would sing if well and it probably would have been produced better.

Even the overall vibe isn't for txt, Still a no for me

TXT can pull of a concept like this, but now I want to see them cover it.

Quote from ellenote

Yes. Imagine a horror concept from them. Imagine it

Not like this for their own discography.

Nah I can't imagine txt ever having given-taken as their song. Firstly, it wouldn't suit their storyline. Enhypen are vampires/werewolves in their storyline, there is some horror elememts too while txt has magical/supernatural elements which come nowhere near horror. Also, the song is about whether enhypen TOOK the opportunity to debut because of their own hard work and efforts or it was GIVEN to them by people. It's connected to the survival show they participated in - something txt hasn't gone through. And lastly, the whole song is nothing like the songs txt put out. The closest that comes to given taken is CYSM and even there are too many differences between the two songs. So yeah, to conclude this, I don't think txt would have suited that song, that's why it was made for enhypen