If Jennie was still an IT girl why can't bp stay #1 on melon?

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.
  • Jennie isn't even the most popular in her group. He glory days are behind her, just like Twice. Wonyoung is the moment, and a bigger It girl as a rookie than Jennie ever was.

  • lol an it girl helps to push the group to the gp but they are not the factor why a song reach #1 on melon

    you are just pressed

  • what got IVE 1 on melon was the excessive promotions, one thing startship does well is to promote their artists and send them to the variety shows they are capitalizing in their popularity by having multiple comebacks this year.


    YG on the other hand is milking fans dry and not even bother to promote blackpink the only reason they are having a comeback is to have new music for their world tour

  • No one in their right minds can actually admit that pink venom is a good song. Its legit awful. Its the BP hype and their name (along with teddy) thats purely carrying it. YG are genius in that aspect all the way from big bang to 2ne1 to bp. They can release pure noise and trash and it will carry them far casue of the image and hype they built for those groups.

  • what got IVE 1 on melon was the excessive promotions, one thing startship does well is to promote their artists and send them to the variety shows they are capitalizing in their popularity by having multiple comebacks this year.


    YG on the other hand is milking fans dry and not even bother to promote blackpink the only reason they are having a comeback is to have new music for their world tour

    It's because people liked afterlike way more than pink venom. No amount of promotions would have made blackpink overtake ive. Ive is out of reach.

  • I think yujin help more to boost the song to GP. Her popularity goes to the drama actress level. you know earth arcade.

  • not sure if this anon comes from a stupid Wonyoung fan or both an Ive and BP hater.


    the think is to drag Jennie and bringing hate to Wonyoung. Cos you know some Blinks will bite and Drag her just because you insulted Jennie. Maybe end up with Ive being Aespa II

  • No one in their right minds can actually admit that pink venom is a good song. Its legit awful. Its the BP hype and their name (along with teddy) thats purely carrying it. YG are genius in that aspect all the way from big bang to 2ne1 to bp. They can release pure noise and trash and it will carry them far casue of the image and hype they built for those groups.

    don’t forget blinks themselves brag that bp can release any trash and it’d still chart high lmfao. they’re legit admitting they’re just success stans and don’t care about the music at all, it was hilariously embarrassing. like idols like fans i guess

  • what has 'It' girl to do with music charting?


    Seolhyun was an it girl, how many songs did AOA chart at #1.

    Apink's Naeun was an it girl,

    heck even SNSD Yoona - after 2012, did all SNSD songs chart at #1.

    Suzy, recently released Satellite - no #1 for her either.


    The only IT girl who is also musically the HIT girl, is IU.


    Poor logic..

  • The only poor logic here is yours. AOA, Apink, MissA would have been complete nugus if they didnt have those It girls that blew up.


    Ive's success is due to Wonyoung, if you can't see that you are stupid. Blackpink is not due to Jennie, it's due to YG and Teddy.


    Exact reason why Wonyoung is a bigger It girl than Jennie at this time. Jennie isn't even the most popular in her group.

  • Then let's just say Wonyoung is the K-Pop It Girl of K-Pop It Girls and move on with our lives. Every time I come in anons there's some variation on this...

  • You wish !!!


    But you'r just seatting on your feeling and she's seatting on her throne :-)

  • The only poor logic here is yours. AOA, Apink, MissA would have been complete nugus if they didnt have those It girls that blew up.


    Ive's success is due to Wonyoung, if you can't see that you are stupid. Blackpink is not due to Jennie, it's due to YG and Teddy.


    Exact reason why Wonyoung is a bigger It girl than Jennie at this time. Jennie isn't even the most popular in her group.

    ok you confirmed you are delusional lol probably trying to push the narrative that Wonyoung is bigger than Jennie when objectively she hasn't made any impact yet other than trending on pann and endorsing a few brands. I hate to break it to you but that's enough that only makes her trendy same like Gidle Soojin was t some point.


    How is Miss A a nugu group? lol Miss A 's debut song bad girl, good girl hit #1 on real time music chart so nope and Suzy became an it girl later when she started to get into acting and it didn't do anything for her group only for her.



    we are discussing Jennie's popularity in South Korea not world wide and every member is popular in certain regions and with some demographics so



  • The only poor logic here is yours. AOA, Apink, MissA would have been complete nugus if they didnt have those It girls that blew up.


    Ive's success is due to Wonyoung, if you can't see that you are stupid. Blackpink is not due to Jennie, it's due to YG and Teddy.


    Exact reason why Wonyoung is a bigger It girl than Jennie at this time. Jennie isn't even the most popular in her group.

    If you are logical, you would not need to use abuse like calling others stupid.


    So according to you ONLY 'it-ness' can blow up a group.


    SISTAR, didn't have an IT girls, yet had 9 back to back #1s

    Twice, none of them are considered IT like Jennie or WY is, also ruled K-pop charts for 3 years.

    Vocal powerhouse like Taeyeon apparently have no role in their groups success.


    "It-ness" is a nice-to-have thing, groups have been successful without an it-girl and have been unsuccessful without an it-girl too.

    So effectively not a critical factor.


    Anyway, seems the intention is to put down Jennie and BP. So twist the data to fit the narrative.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!