if you stan for the music then you're a company stan

more like, a stan of their producer

For example, if I like Blackpink for their music and dislike a YG bg for their music, what am I? A semi-company stan?

Quote from bobsyouruncle

how can you claim to be a stan of the group because of the music / concept when your faves aren't responsible for the production and composition of that music or have any hand in the concept?

i'm talking about the stans who when it comes to reasons they stan its all "i love their concept" "i love their songs" at that point you stan the company .. on that note this is why groups with good music happen to have the highest percentage of company stans, the higher quality of their music ensures that they have more people keeping an eye on debuts and watching every artists comeback

Self produced groups do have more control (I think), but I also see your point.

Also, while you're right, different groups from the same company can have VERY different sounds. Twice, Nmixx, NiziU and Itzy sound very different from each other for example (in terms of music).

I do think your last point points out something I foolishly didn't notice before, and that explains a lot of things to me.

Quote from bobsyouruncle

this is a personal attack on STAYC stans

LOL

Yeaaa StayC's music stans is 100% company stans then

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

For example, if I like Blackpink for their music and dislike a YG bg for their music, what am I? A semi-company stan?

Kitty's gotten to you too, hasn't she?

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

For example, if I like Blackpink for their music and dislike a YG bg for their music, what am I? A semi-company stan?

yes, it just that you're not the pure-blooded ones

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

For example, if I like Blackpink for their music and dislike a YG bg for their music, what am I? A semi-company stan?

if I only stan 2 Hybe groups am I a company stan

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Kitty's gotten to you too, hasn't she?

Nope it's just an example

I won't take example from a furry

Yes, I like EXO

Quote from doki-doki

if I only stan 2 Hybe groups am I a company stan

it depends on the number of groups in that company.

If it's half it's semi, etc...

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

Nope it's just an example

I won't take example from a furry

If I say I'm a furry, does that mean you'll quit asking for akorns from me?

Let's continue this in the guild so we don't derail the thread.

Quote from ponder

Yes, I like EXO

I understood that reference.

Quote from YouChanDoThis

If I say I'm a furry, does that mean you'll quit asking for akorns from me?

Let's continue this in the guild so we don't derail the thread.

Yeah just a joke.

And what is your take on this topic?

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

Yeah just a joke.

And what is your take on this topic?

Posted above but since you're probably too lazy to look, here:

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Self produced groups do have more control (I think), but I also see your point.

Also, while you're right, different groups from the same company can have VERY different sounds. Twice, Nmixx, NiziU and Itzy sound very different from each other for example (in terms of music).

I do think your last point points out something I foolishly didn't notice before, and that explains a lot of things to me.

Quote from bobsyouruncle

why do you think people stan everglow? a nugus version of blackpink

Nice trigger

Quote from bobsyouruncle

how can you claim to be a stan of the group because of the music / concept when your faves aren't responsible for the production and composition of that music or have any hand in the concept?

and if one my fav is the most credited female artist in the whole korea ?

Quote from bobsyouruncle

which groups and how did you become aware of them?

BTS, kind of organically found them in 2017!

Now I’m interested in New Jeans, but I think my attraction is moreso the r&b, y2k 2000s vibes that is singing to my old soul more than anything! (And I loved f(x) so there’s that)

I paid like all the other Hybe groups dust tbh, I can’t even name them many of them

even within the parameters of production the style of an artist is completely different from the other

If my faves chose the members that would debut in the group, chose the name, hand wrote the logo, built the concepts, wrote/produced/arranged the discography, pick the songs that were released... then I stan the group?

Quote from bobsyouruncle

so you're an SM stan

I like old school SM lmao! f(x) and snsd I guess!

Quote from bobsyouruncle

if she produces her own music or plays a part in the production of it then you would be stanning her as an artist

I already stan her as an artist

Quote from Minazuki

If my faves chose the members that would debut in the group, chose the name, hand wrote the logo, built the concepts, wrote/produced/arranged the discography, pick the songs that were released... than I stan the group?

you're jyp stan mina don't deny it

Quote from bobsyouruncle

the exact groups min heejin worked on

She can step on me any day

Quote from citron-icy

you're jyp stan mina don't deny it

Shhh, why are you killing my vibe